You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: The Stupidity of Hivewatchers

Yes. Thanks for pointing that out.

OpenAI’s classifier tool is pretty much worthless, though.

It only flags its own output 25% of the time. And it only takes slight modifications of its own output to fool the classifier even when it otherwise would catch it.

And, it’s easy for students to just keep making small changes then running it through the classifier until it’s “safe” to submit.

Sort:  

I'm also a college professor. I think the answer will be oral exams in the future. Students can't take the knowledge they have. Chatgtp can only get you so far

Of course Oral exams immediately comes to mind as a solution. However, it is necessary to acknowledge that writing is a different process, and engages different parts of the brain. I am almost an incompetent speaker, yet I feel far more competent writing.

I suggest including extemporaneous essay questions as part of your assessment of your students. After all, despite the advent of AI, writing will remain an essential human skill going forward.

Edit: until Neuralink is common.

exactly... but the saddest thing is that as time pass, AI will always be smarter and humans that use them at a regular basis will always be more retarded.
Look at the damage done by calculators... go on the street and find a teenager that is able to do mental calculus... you will be lucky if you find some. Instead go on street and make the same math question to an old man/women, 99.99% he/she is able to reply to you.
That's a sad reality.

I've taken calculus. I'm not sure many ever could do it in their head. However, I do know that the fastest I ever got at calculating in my head was when I was actively buying and selling real estate. I could do a price per square foot calculation very quickly on the fly. The more you use it, the better you are. If you never write your own papers or study, pop quizzes and oral exams will work you over something fierce

go on the street and find a teenager that is able to do mental calculus... you will be lucky if you find some.

A teenager that is able to do mental calculus? Ha, many of them are even unable to tell the hour on a clock with hands! LoL

ahah indeed one time i taught to read the clock to a 14 years old guy. I'm not joking

Hahaha, yeah! Indeed! I bet you are not joking.