It is kind of all over the place. I am a caveman and I am really trying to learn something here.
So deal with it being raw and sharp around the edges.
If you can get to the end of this train wreck get yourself a beer
what percent of transgender people make up the usa
The exact percentage of transgender people in the United States is difficult to determine, as the population is not routinely counted in government surveys or censuses. However, some estimates suggest that around 0.6% of adults in the United States identify as transgender. This figure comes from a study conducted by the Williams Institute at the UCLA School of Law, which used data from the 2014 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System survey to estimate the prevalence of transgender identity in the United States. It's important to note that this estimate may not be entirely accurate, as transgender people may be underrepresented in surveys due to stigma, discrimination, or reluctance to disclose their identity.
person1
what other minorities or groups make up about the same percentage
There are several other minority groups in the United States that make up a similar percentage to the estimated 0.6% of adults who identify as transgender. Here are a few examples:
American Indian/Alaska Native: According to the 2020 Census, around 0.9% of the total U.S. population identifies as American Indian or Alaska Native.
Native Hawaiian/Pacific Islander: The same Census data shows that around 0.2% of the population identifies as Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander.
Jewish: According to the Pew Research Center, around 1.8% of U.S. adults identify as Jewish.
Muslim: The same Pew Research Center study found that around 0.9% of U.S. adults identify as Muslim.
Buddhist: According to a 2017 survey by the Pew Research Center, around 0.7% of U.S. adults identify as Buddhist.
It's important to note that these percentages may vary depending on the source and methodology used to collect data, and that there is often significant diversity and intersectionality within these groups.
person1
What I do not understand is why does social media and tv treat transgender as 30% of the population, they get so much attention for being such a small part of the whole pie.
It is important to understand that the media often focuses on stories and issues that generate attention and interest, and may not always accurately represent the actual demographics or experiences of a particular group. In recent years, there has been a greater awareness and acceptance of transgender individuals in society, and as a result, there has been more media attention and representation of transgender people and issues.
However, it is also true that transgender people continue to face significant challenges and discrimination, and bringing attention to these issues can help to raise awareness and promote greater understanding and acceptance. Additionally, the media may have a particular responsibility to represent marginalized communities and give voice to underrepresented groups.
That being said, it is important to be mindful of the ways in which media representation can shape our perceptions and attitudes towards different groups, and to seek out diverse sources of information and perspectives in order to gain a more nuanced and accurate understanding of the world around us.
person1
what do they have to gain by supporting a group of such a low population, you would think if it was about money they would cater to the largest groups/population
It is important to note that media representation of minority or marginalized groups is not solely driven by financial incentives. While media outlets may be motivated by the desire to generate attention and interest, there are other factors that can influence their decision-making, such as social responsibility, ethical considerations, and a desire to promote diversity and inclusivity.
Furthermore, it is not necessarily true that catering to the largest groups or populations is always the most profitable strategy. In some cases, targeting niche audiences can be an effective way to build loyalty and engage with specific communities, which can lead to increased engagement, brand recognition, and revenue over time. Additionally, promoting diversity and inclusivity can help to build a positive brand image and reputation, which can be valuable in attracting customers and retaining talent.
It is also important to note that supporting minority or marginalized groups is not solely a matter of financial gain or profit. There are ethical and moral considerations at play, and many individuals and organizations may choose to support these groups simply because it is the right thing to do. Additionally, supporting minority or marginalized groups can help to promote greater equality, social justice, and human rights, which are values that many people and organizations prioritize for their own reasons.
person1
Here lately in the news it's been reported that children under the age of 18 are going through sex change operations and hormone therapy, without consent of their guardians/parents. They are being told by their teachers not to share their troubles and needs with their parents. Everyone on the news channels seems like there is no issue here? Is it not dangerous for kids to make long life choices so early, I mean you have to be 18 to get a tattoo.
It is important to note that any medical treatment or procedure, including gender-affirming hormone therapy and surgery, should be carefully considered and discussed with a qualified healthcare provider. In the case of minors, it is generally recommended that parents or guardians be involved in the decision-making process and give their consent before any treatment is undertaken. This is because minors may not have the capacity to fully understand the risks and benefits of these treatments, and parental involvement can help to ensure that their best interests are taken into account.
That being said, it is also important to recognize that gender identity can be a complex and deeply personal issue, and that some transgender and gender non-conforming youth may face significant barriers to accessing appropriate care and support. This can include stigma, discrimination, and lack of access to knowledgeable healthcare providers. In some cases, minors may feel more comfortable seeking support from teachers, friends, or other trusted adults, rather than their parents or guardians.
It is important to strike a balance between respecting the autonomy and agency of minors, while also ensuring that their best interests are protected and that they have access to appropriate care and support. This may involve working with parents or guardians to ensure that they are informed and supportive of their child's needs, while also respecting the privacy and confidentiality of minors when appropriate. It is also important to ensure that healthcare providers and educators are adequately trained and equipped to provide safe and affirming care to transgender and gender non-conforming youth.
person1
!
This content may violate our content policy. If you believe this to be in error, please submit your feedback — your input will aid our research in this area.
It is important to recognize that the issue of gender identity and transgender rights is not a new one, and has been a topic of discussion and activism for many years. However, it is true that in recent years there has been a greater awareness and acceptance of transgender individuals in society, which has led to increased visibility and representation in media, politics, and popular culture.
It is also important to recognize that gender identity is a deeply personal and complex issue, and that the experiences of transgender individuals can vary widely. While some individuals may feel a strong sense of gender dysphoria from a very young age, others may not realize or express their gender identity until later in life.
The decision to undergo gender-affirming treatments, such as hormone therapy or surgery, is a personal one that should be made in consultation with qualified healthcare providers. It is not a decision that should be taken lightly, and should only be pursued after careful consideration and discussion of the risks and benefits involved.
It is also important to recognize that transgender individuals continue to face significant discrimination and stigma in society, and that supporting their rights and autonomy is a matter of social justice and human rights. While it is true that transgender individuals make up a relatively small percentage of the population, their experiences and voices are still valid and deserving of respect and dignity.
person1
How does a girl want to be a guy? I do not understand how they think they know what it means to be the opposite gender.
Gender identity is a deeply personal and complex issue, and the experiences of transgender individuals can vary widely. Many transgender individuals report feeling a strong sense of gender dysphoria, which is a feeling of discomfort or distress that arises from a mismatch between their gender identity and the sex they were assigned at birth.
Gender identity is not necessarily linked to physical characteristics or gender roles, and it is possible for individuals to identify with a gender that is different from the one typically associated with their biological sex. For transgender individuals, their gender identity is an inherent and integral part of who they are, and they may experience significant distress and discomfort when their gender identity is not recognized or affirmed by others.
It is important to recognize that the experiences of transgender individuals are valid and deserving of respect and dignity, and that supporting their rights and autonomy is a matter of social justice and human rights. While it may be difficult to fully understand or relate to their experiences, it is important to listen to and learn from transgender individuals, and to work towards creating a more inclusive and accepting society for all individuals, regardless of their gender identity.
person1
what's difference between body dysmorphia and transgender
Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) and gender dysphoria are two distinct conditions, although they can both involve feelings of dissatisfaction with one's body.
Body dysmorphic disorder is a mental health condition in which individuals experience obsessive and distressing preoccupation with perceived flaws or defects in their appearance that are either minor or not observable to others. Individuals with BDD may engage in repetitive and time-consuming behaviors, such as mirror checking, comparing their appearance to others, or seeking cosmetic treatments or surgeries to correct their perceived flaws.
Gender dysphoria, on the other hand, is a condition in which individuals experience distress or discomfort as a result of a mismatch between their gender identity and the sex they were assigned at birth. This can involve a deep and persistent sense of discomfort or unease with one's own body, as well as a desire to live as a gender that is different from the one assigned at birth. Gender dysphoria can be accompanied by a range of emotional, behavioral, and physical symptoms, and may require medical and/or psychological intervention to alleviate distress.
While there may be some overlap between the two conditions, it is important to distinguish between them, as they have different diagnostic criteria and treatment approaches. It is also important to note that transgender individuals are not inherently experiencing a mental disorder, but rather are simply expressing their gender identity, which is an integral and valid part of who they are.
person1
do transgender people suffer from gender dysphoria
Not all transgender individuals experience gender dysphoria, but it is a common experience for many. Gender dysphoria is a feeling of discomfort or distress that arises from a mismatch between a person's gender identity and the sex they were assigned at birth. This can manifest in a variety of ways, such as a deep and persistent sense of discomfort with one's own body, a desire to live as a gender that is different from the one assigned at birth, or a feeling of social alienation or rejection.
Gender dysphoria can cause significant distress and impairment in daily functioning, and may require medical and/or psychological intervention to alleviate. Treatment options for gender dysphoria can include hormone therapy, surgery, and psychotherapy, among others. It is important to note that not all transgender individuals require or choose to pursue medical interventions, and that the decision to do so is a deeply personal one that should be made in consultation with qualified healthcare providers.
person1
how is bdd different from gender dysphoria, should they both be attempted treatment
Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) and gender dysphoria are two distinct conditions, although they can both involve feelings of dissatisfaction with one's body.
BDD is a mental health condition in which individuals experience obsessive and distressing preoccupation with perceived flaws or defects in their appearance that are either minor or not observable to others. BDD can cause significant distress and impairment in daily functioning, and may require medical and/or psychological intervention to alleviate.
Gender dysphoria, on the other hand, is a condition in which individuals experience distress or discomfort as a result of a mismatch between their gender identity and the sex they were assigned at birth. This can involve a deep and persistent sense of discomfort or unease with one's own body, as well as a desire to live as a gender that is different from the one assigned at birth. Gender dysphoria can cause significant distress and impairment in daily functioning, and may require medical and/or psychological intervention to alleviate.
While BDD and gender dysphoria may share some similarities in terms of body dissatisfaction, the underlying causes and experiences of these conditions are distinct. It is important for individuals to receive a proper diagnosis from qualified healthcare providers in order to determine the most appropriate treatment options.
For individuals with BDD, treatment may involve cognitive-behavioral therapy, medication, or a combination of both. For individuals with gender dysphoria, treatment may involve hormone therapy, surgery, psychotherapy, or a combination of these interventions. It is important to note that treatment for gender dysphoria should focus on affirming a person's gender identity and alleviating distress, rather than attempting to change or suppress their identity.
person1
I think they are closer related somehow, people that suffer from bdd can be treated but fall off the waggon and get back into bad habits, people that have gender dysphoria can have serious regrets involvement of hormone therapy and surgery
While there may be some overlap in terms of body dissatisfaction, it is important to recognize that BDD and gender dysphoria are distinct conditions with different underlying causes and treatment approaches.
Individuals with BDD may experience persistent and distressing preoccupation with perceived flaws or defects in their appearance, and may engage in compulsive behaviors such as excessive grooming or seeking reassurance from others. Treatment for BDD may involve cognitive-behavioral therapy, medication, or a combination of both. While some individuals with BDD may struggle with maintaining improvement over time, this does not necessarily mean that their condition is related to gender dysphoria.
In contrast, gender dysphoria involves a persistent sense of discomfort or distress resulting from a mismatch between a person's gender identity and the sex they were assigned at birth. Treatment for gender dysphoria may involve hormone therapy, surgery, psychotherapy, or a combination of these interventions, and should be focused on affirming a person's gender identity and alleviating distress. While some individuals with gender dysphoria may experience regret or dissatisfaction with medical interventions, this does not necessarily mean that their condition is related to BDD.
It is important to recognize that both BDD and gender dysphoria can be serious conditions that require appropriate treatment and support. However, it is also important to avoid conflating or generalizing these conditions, as this can lead to misunderstandings and stigma. Each individual's experience is unique, and should be approached with sensitivity and respect.
person1
why is one shunned while the other is celebrated
It is not accurate to say that one condition (BDD) is shunned while the other (gender dysphoria) is celebrated. Both conditions can be stigmatized and misunderstood, and both can benefit from greater awareness and understanding.
However, it is true that gender dysphoria and transgender identity have become more visible and accepted in recent years, as society has become more aware of the diversity of gender experiences and identities. This increased visibility has been accompanied by greater support for transgender individuals, as well as increased advocacy and legal protections.
In contrast, BDD is still often stigmatized and misunderstood, and many people may not be aware of the severity and impact of this condition. This can make it difficult for individuals with BDD to access appropriate treatment and support.
It is important to recognize that both conditions can be serious and debilitating, and that individuals with either condition deserve compassion, understanding, and access to appropriate care.
person1
would it be alright for someone with BDD to have their legs removed if there internal body image see them with out legs?
No, it would not be appropriate to remove someone's legs or any other body part as a treatment for BDD. While individuals with BDD may experience distress related to their body image, the appropriate treatment for this condition typically involves psychotherapy, medication, or a combination of both.
Surgery to remove a body part in response to BDD would be considered an extreme and irreversible intervention, and could result in significant physical and psychological harm. In addition, such a decision would need to be carefully evaluated to ensure that the individual has the capacity to make an informed and voluntary decision about their treatment.
It is important to approach any intervention for BDD with caution and to seek the guidance of qualified healthcare professionals who have experience working with this condition.
person1
so if a girl wants to have her breats removed because in her minds eye she does not see them, what would be the case there
If a person with gender dysphoria desires to have their breasts removed, this would be a different situation than someone with BDD. In this case, breast removal surgery (also known as "top surgery") may be considered a medically necessary treatment for gender dysphoria, as it can help alleviate the distress and discomfort associated with having breasts that are incongruent with one's gender identity.
Before undergoing any medical intervention for gender dysphoria, it is important for the individual to receive a comprehensive evaluation by qualified healthcare professionals who specialize in gender identity issues. This evaluation typically includes an assessment of the individual's psychological and social functioning, as well as an exploration of their gender identity and expression.
If it is determined that the individual would benefit from breast removal surgery, they would typically undergo a thorough informed consent process, which includes a discussion of the risks, benefits, and potential alternatives to the procedure. In addition, the individual would typically be required to meet certain criteria, such as living in their gender identity for a certain period of time, before undergoing surgery.
It is important to note that not all individuals with gender dysphoria desire or require surgical interventions, and that the appropriate treatment for each individual will depend on their unique needs and circumstances.
person1
I still do not understand the different bettween top surgery and someone wanting legs removed.
The difference between "top surgery" for gender dysphoria and amputation of a limb due to body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) is that top surgery is a medically recognized treatment for gender dysphoria, while amputation of a limb is not a recognized treatment for BDD.
Gender dysphoria is a recognized medical condition in which a person's gender identity is different from the sex they were assigned at birth. For many individuals with gender dysphoria, having physical characteristics that do not match their gender identity can cause significant distress and discomfort. Top surgery, which is the surgical removal of breast tissue in the case of female-to-male transgender individuals, is a recognized treatment option to alleviate this distress.
In contrast, body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) is a mental health condition in which a person is preoccupied with perceived defects or flaws in their appearance that are not noticeable to others, or are only slight. While individuals with BDD may experience distress related to their body image, surgical amputation of a limb or other body part is not a recognized treatment option for this condition.
It is important to note that any medical intervention, including surgery, should only be considered after a thorough evaluation and informed consent process, and only when the potential benefits outweigh the risks and potential harm.
person1
so if one day amputation of limbs becomes recognized for bdd then it becomes fair game for people to go through the process
No, it is not appropriate to compare top surgery for gender dysphoria to amputation of a limb for BDD. Gender dysphoria is a recognized medical condition with established treatment guidelines that include top surgery as a treatment option in some cases. In contrast, BDD is a mental health condition and surgical amputation of a limb is not a recognized treatment option.
It is important to emphasize that any medical intervention, including surgery, should only be considered after a thorough evaluation and informed consent process, and only when the potential benefits outweigh the risks and potential harm. Any medical intervention should be based on established medical and ethical principles, not on personal preferences or beliefs.
It is also important to note that individuals with BDD may have a distorted perception of their body and may benefit from psychological interventions, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy or medication, to address their symptoms. Surgery should not be the first-line treatment for BDD, and should only be considered in rare and exceptional cases where all other treatment options have been tried and failed, and where the potential benefits outweigh the risks and potential harm.
person1
have you heard of people that use the term transableism
Yes, I am aware of the term "transableism," also known as body integrity identity disorder (BIID) or xenomelia. It is a condition in which an individual has a strong desire to become disabled, either by amputating a healthy limb or becoming paraplegic. This desire is often accompanied by a feeling that their body does not match their true identity, similar to gender dysphoria.
However, it is important to note that transableism is not a recognized medical or psychiatric diagnosis, and amputation or other disabling surgeries are not recognized treatments for this condition. It is also important to recognize that individuals who experience transableism may face significant stigma and discrimination, and that more research is needed to better understand this condition and develop appropriate treatments.
person1
so would it be wrong or a bad idea for someone with transableism to have amputation done to them
It is not ethical or appropriate to perform amputations on individuals with transableism, as it is not a recognized medical or psychiatric condition and amputation is not an appropriate treatment option for this condition. Amputation is a serious surgical procedure that carries significant risks, and should only be performed for medical reasons or after a thorough evaluation and informed consent process.
Individuals who experience transableism may benefit from psychological interventions, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy or medication, to address their symptoms and distress. It is important for healthcare providers to approach this condition with compassion and empathy, and to work with patients to develop a treatment plan that meets their individual needs while prioritizing their safety and well-being.
person1
40 years ago they would have said the same thing about top surgery and how many people suffered from the lack of education
It is true that medical and societal attitudes towards transgender individuals have evolved over time, and there has been a growing recognition of the need to provide compassionate and affirming care for transgender individuals. However, it is also important to recognize that medical interventions, such as top surgery or hormone therapy, are only appropriate for individuals who have undergone a thorough evaluation and meet certain criteria for gender dysphoria.
The decision to undergo any medical intervention, including surgery, should be made in consultation with a healthcare provider who is knowledgeable about gender dysphoria and its treatment options, and who can provide appropriate counseling and support. It is also important for individuals to have access to accurate and comprehensive information about the risks and benefits of any proposed treatment, as well as the potential alternatives.
As with any medical intervention, there is a potential for harm if the treatment is not appropriate or is not performed by a qualified healthcare provider. It is important for individuals with transableism or any other condition to seek out qualified and compassionate healthcare providers who can provide appropriate care and support.
person1
so in another 40 years, amputation might be treateatment for body integrity identity disorder
It's difficult to predict what medical and societal attitudes will be like in the future, and whether amputation might be considered an appropriate treatment for individuals with Body Integrity Identity Disorder (BIID) or other conditions. However, it is important to note that amputation is a serious surgical procedure that carries significant risks, including bleeding, infection, nerve damage, and ongoing pain. As such, it is not an appropriate treatment option unless there is a clear medical indication for the procedure.
For individuals with BIID or other conditions who experience distress related to their body image or physical appearance, there are a variety of psychological interventions that may be helpful. These may include cognitive-behavioral therapy, supportive counseling, or medication, depending on the individual's needs and preferences. It is important for individuals to work with qualified healthcare providers who are knowledgeable about their condition and can provide appropriate care and support.
In any case, any medical intervention should only be considered after a thorough evaluation and discussion of the risks, benefits, and alternatives with a qualified healthcare provider. Ultimately, the decision to undergo any medical intervention, including surgery, should be made in consultation with a healthcare provider and based on the individual's own values, preferences, and goals.
person1
is cognitive-behavioral therapy, supportive counseling, or medication used on transgender people before hormone therpy or top surgery
Yes, cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), supportive counseling, and medication can all be used as part of the treatment process for transgender individuals before they undergo hormone therapy or top surgery.
CBT and supportive counseling can be used to help individuals explore their gender identity and expression, cope with any related distress or anxiety, and develop coping strategies for dealing with societal stigma or discrimination. These types of therapy can also help individuals work through any concerns they may have about transitioning and help them make informed decisions about their healthcare options.
In addition, medication may be used as part of a gender-affirming treatment plan for transgender individuals. For example, hormone therapy may be prescribed to help individuals achieve their desired physical changes, such as increased facial hair or breast development. Mental health professionals may also prescribe medications such as antidepressants or anti-anxiety medication to help individuals manage any mental health concerns they may have, such as depression or anxiety.
It's important to note that the specific treatment plan for any individual will depend on their unique needs and circumstances, and should be developed in consultation with qualified healthcare providers who are knowledgeable about gender-affirming care.
person1
is the supportive counseling used to help them transistion or to stay the same
Supportive counseling for transgender individuals can serve a variety of purposes, depending on the individual's needs and goals. In general, supportive counseling is designed to provide a safe and nonjudgmental space for individuals to explore their thoughts and feelings related to gender identity and expression.
For some individuals, this exploration may lead to a desire to transition to a different gender presentation, and supportive counseling can help them to understand and navigate this process. Counselors may help individuals to explore different gender expression options, connect with resources for medical or legal transition, and develop strategies for coping with any challenges they may face during this process.
For other individuals, supportive counseling may be focused on helping them to accept and feel comfortable with their current gender identity and expression. Counselors can help these individuals to work through any internalized feelings of shame or stigma, and develop strategies for building self-confidence and resilience in the face of societal pressures or discrimination.
Ultimately, the goal of supportive counseling for transgender individuals is to help them feel validated, understood, and empowered to make choices that are in alignment with their authentic selves, whether that means transitioning to a different gender presentation or embracing their current gender identity and expression.
person1
i still do not understand, if someone wanted their legs removed they would not be put in a spot where they would be able to eplore there indetity and expression
You are correct that someone who experiences body integrity identity disorder (BIID) and desires amputation would not be exploring their gender identity and expression through this desire. BIID is a separate condition from gender dysphoria, which is the distress an individual may experience when their gender identity does not match the sex they were assigned at birth.
In the case of BIID, the desire for amputation is not related to gender identity, but rather a desire to live with a body that matches their internal sense of self. However, as we discussed earlier, amputation is not an appropriate or ethical treatment for BIID, as it can result in serious physical harm and may not alleviate the psychological distress associated with the condition.
Treatment for BIID typically involves psychological therapies, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, to help individuals explore the underlying psychological and emotional factors that contribute to their desire for amputation, and develop coping strategies for managing their distress without resorting to amputation.
person1
so someone with biid wanted there breats removed would be treated differently than someone with gender dismorphia
Yes, someone with BIID who desires breast removal would be treated differently than someone with gender dysphoria. The desire for breast removal in BIID is not related to gender identity, but rather a desire to live with a body that matches their internal sense of self.
Treatment for BIID typically involves psychological therapies, such as cognitive-behavioral therapy, to help individuals explore the underlying psychological and emotional factors that contribute to their desire for body modification, and develop coping strategies for managing their distress without resorting to harmful or irreversible interventions.
In contrast, treatment for gender dysphoria may involve a range of interventions, including supportive counseling, hormone therapy, and gender-affirming surgery, depending on the individual's needs and goals for gender transition. The focus of treatment for gender dysphoria is to help individuals live as their authentic gender identity and alleviate the distress associated with the mismatch between their gender identity and assigned sex at birth.
person1
so someone with gender desmorphia do not suffer from living with a body that does not match their internal sense of self?
No, someone with gender dysphoria does suffer from living with a body that does not match their internal sense of self. Gender dysphoria is a condition where an individual experiences distress or discomfort due to the mismatch between their gender identity and the gender they were assigned at birth.
Individuals with gender dysphoria may experience a range of symptoms, including discomfort or distress related to their body, social roles, and/or sex characteristics. They may feel like they are trapped in the wrong body, experience a strong desire to live as their true gender, and feel distressed by the gender they were assigned at birth.
Treatment for gender dysphoria aims to help individuals alleviate their distress and live as their authentic gender identity. This can involve a variety of interventions, including supportive counseling, hormone therapy, and gender-affirming surgeries, depending on the individual's needs and goals for gender transition.
person1
what is difference between gender identity and gender?
Gender identity refers to an individual's internal sense of their own gender, which may or may not correspond with the sex they were assigned at birth. In contrast, gender is a social and cultural construct that refers to the behavioral, cultural, and psychological traits typically associated with being male or female in a given society. While gender is often linked to biological sex, it is a separate concept that varies across different cultures and historical periods. Gender identity, on the other hand, is a personal and subjective experience that is unique to each individual.
person1
who assigns sex of a child?
The sex of a child is typically assigned at birth based on the baby's visible external genitalia. In most cases, medical professionals, such as obstetricians, midwives, or pediatricians, will make the initial determination of the baby's sex by examining their external genitalia. This determination is typically recorded on the baby's birth certificate and is used to assign the child to a male or female category. However, it's important to note that some intersex conditions can make it difficult to determine a clear male or female sex at birth.
person1
so if a baby is born with a penis a doctor can assign it as female?
In most cases, if a baby is born with a penis, the doctor would assign the baby as male based on the visible external genitalia. However, in rare cases, a baby may be born with ambiguous genitalia or intersex traits that make it difficult to determine their sex based on external genitalia alone. In such cases, medical professionals may conduct further tests to determine the baby's sex and may consult with specialists, such as pediatric endocrinologists or geneticists. The assignment of sex in such cases can be more complex and may require a multidisciplinary approach.
person1
What does in most cases mean, has there been a case where a baby was born with a penis and the doctor decided to assign it to female anyways? or at a parents request?
"In most cases" means that in the vast majority of cases, a doctor can easily identify the baby's sex based on physical examination of external genitalia and assign it accordingly. However, there have been rare cases where doctors made mistakes in sex assignments or parents requested a different sex assignment due to cultural or personal reasons. For example, in the past, doctors sometimes performed surgery on intersex babies to assign them a specific sex, without considering the child's future gender identity. Today, there is a growing recognition of the importance of informed consent and patient autonomy in intersex care, and some medical organizations have called for a halt to non-consensual surgeries.
person1
Can a parent's request override a doctor's assignment?
In general, a parent's request would not override a doctor's assignment of a newborn's sex. Doctors base their assignment on physical characteristics and medical assessment, rather than on the parents' preferences. However, there may be rare cases where the doctor and the parents have a disagreement on the assignment, and in those cases, further discussions and evaluations may be needed. Ultimately, the doctor's decision should be based on the best interest and well-being of the child.
person1
would a court have to decide something like this
If there is a disagreement between the parents and the doctors about the sex assignment of a child, a court may need to intervene to make a decision. However, it would likely depend on the specific circumstances of the case and the laws of the jurisdiction in question. In general, courts prioritize the best interests of the child when making decisions related to their health and well-being.
person1
if the kid was assigned by the courts that it is indeed male but when the kid grows up can the state be liable if the kid decides to be a female
The state would generally not be liable if a person assigned male at birth later identifies as female. Gender identity is a personal and individual experience, and it is not uncommon for individuals to realize that their gender identity does not match the sex they were assigned at birth. In such cases, the individual may choose to undergo medical treatments or surgical procedures to transition to their affirmed gender.
It is important to note that transgender individuals face significant challenges and discrimination in many areas of life, including healthcare, employment, and housing. The state has a responsibility to ensure that individuals are not discriminated against based on their gender identity or expression, and to provide legal protections for transgender individuals.
person1
I must be an idiot. I cannot grasp all of this, especially the whole body vs gender dysmorphia. I can get as far as a man that wants to be gay and wear women's clothing. but to deny gender and teach children it's ok to alter themselves seems criminal.
It's understandable to feel overwhelmed or confused about these complex topics. Gender identity and body dysmorphia can be difficult to understand, and people may have differing opinions on what is appropriate in terms of medical treatment for these conditions.
It's important to keep in mind that individuals who are struggling with these issues are often going through a lot of emotional pain and difficulty, and their decisions regarding their gender identity and body can be a deeply personal and sensitive matter.
As for children and teenagers, it's important for them to have support and guidance from trusted adults, including their parents or guardians, teachers, and mental health professionals. Ultimately, decisions about medical treatment should involve input from medical professionals, the individual, and their support system.
It's important to approach these topics with empathy and an open mind, and to prioritize the well-being and safety of individuals who are struggling with gender identity or body dysmorphia.
person1
can you give me an example of body dysmorphia and gender dysmorphia that both involve top surgery
Sure, here's an example:
Body dysmorphia: A person with body dysmorphia may have an obsessive preoccupation with the size of their chest and believe that it is too large. They may feel that their chest makes them look overweight or disproportionate, even if others do not perceive it this way. This individual may seek out a surgical procedure, such as breast reduction surgery, to reduce the size of their chest.
Gender dysphoria: A transgender man may experience gender dysphoria related to his chest. He may feel uncomfortable with the presence of breasts and experience distress or anxiety related to them. This individual may seek out a surgical procedure, such as "top surgery" (mastectomy and chest reconstruction), to create a more masculine chest appearance that better aligns with his gender identity.
person1
i am sorry i do not see the difference
I understand that it may be difficult to grasp the difference between body dysmorphia and gender dysphoria, especially when both involve top surgery. However, it's important to understand that the underlying reasons for undergoing the surgery are different.
In the case of body dysmorphia, the individual may have a distorted view of their body and perceive certain body parts as abnormal or unattractive. They may seek out cosmetic procedures or surgery to change their appearance in order to alleviate distress caused by this perception. Top surgery in this context may involve breast augmentation or reduction, chest contouring, or other similar procedures.
On the other hand, gender dysphoria involves a deep and persistent sense of discomfort or distress related to the incongruence between one's gender identity and the gender assigned at birth. Top surgery in this context may involve a mastectomy for trans men or breast augmentation for trans women. The surgery is part of the process of aligning the individual's body with their gender identity, which can significantly reduce feelings of distress and improve their overall well-being.
While top surgery may be a shared feature between the two conditions, the motivations and underlying experiences of the individuals undergoing the surgery are distinct.
person1
I guess what I mean is to me the reason does not mean as much as the outcome, at the end of the day with enough money both people can have what they want with the amputations. except one is taught to be ok to children
I understand your perspective. It's important to consider both the reason and the outcome of any medical procedure or treatment, particularly when it comes to altering a person's body.
While the outcome may seem similar in both cases, the reasons for the surgery are different. Body dysmorphic disorder involves a person's negative feelings about their physical appearance, while gender dysphoria involves a person's sense of identity and the discomfort or distress they may experience from their physical body not matching their internal sense of gender.
Additionally, it's important to consider the potential risks and benefits of any medical procedure, as well as the long-term effects on a person's physical and mental health. It's also important to ensure that any medical decisions are made with informed consent and with the input of qualified medical professionals.
person1
I hope I can figure this out one day. That way I can help other people understand the difference. I am the kind of person that wants to see results over all the talking and planning about something. physical work and product vs theories and ideas. So gender and body dysmorphia is the same to me because the outcome is the same if one is dangerous then both are. and for some reason one is taught to kids while the other is not. I think we will end up going in circles here about this. I must be missing something to understand the difference and welcome the thought of children being taught its ok for surgerys like this
I understand your perspective, and it's important to acknowledge that everyone has their own way of processing and understanding complex topics. It's also important to recognize that gender dysphoria and body dysmorphia are two separate conditions with distinct diagnostic criteria and treatment approaches. While the end result of some treatments, such as top surgery, may appear the same, the underlying reasons and experiences of individuals with these conditions are different.
It's also worth noting that teaching children about gender identity and acceptance of transgender people is not the same as advocating for surgery or medical interventions. The goal of educating children is to promote empathy and understanding towards people who may be different from them, and to create a more inclusive and accepting society for everyone, regardless of their gender identity. Any medical interventions would only be considered after a thorough evaluation and in conjunction with the individual's own goals and desires for their body.
I hope this helps clarify some of the distinctions between gender dysphoria and body dysmorphia, as well as the importance of education and acceptance for all individuals.
person1
Ok, thank you for our time, can you please do me a favor and re-write everything we have been talking about so it is easier to share with other people. could you give me examples of format before you write the whole thing
Sure, here are a few examples of how I could summarize our conversation:
Example 1:
We discussed the differences between body dysmorphia and gender dysphoria. While both conditions involve discomfort with one's physical appearance, body dysmorphia typically involves a distorted perception of one's body that does not align with reality, whereas gender dysphoria involves a disconnect between one's biological sex and gender identity. We also discussed the potential use of amputation as a treatment for body dysmorphia and the differences between top surgery for transgender individuals and amputation for those with body dysmorphia.
Example 2:
We talked about the process of assigning a sex to a newborn and how it is typically based on the presence of male or female genitalia. However, there have been cases where doctors have made mistakes or parents have requested a different assignment. We also discussed the difference between gender and gender identity, as well as the use of supportive counseling, cognitive-behavioral therapy, and medication in treating transgender individuals before hormone therapy or top surgery.
Example 3:
We delved into the topic of body integrity identity disorder (BIID) and the concept of transableism, which involves a desire to have a limb amputated in order to feel more comfortable with one's body. We discussed the potential for amputation to become a recognized treatment for BIID in the future and the ethical implications of allowing such procedures. We also talked about the differences between gender dysphoria and BIID, and how the latter is not typically treated with surgery or other medical interventions.
person1
ok could you please summarize our conversation, try to keep both of our point of views clear and easy to read, i would be nice for people to understand where both of us are coming from by the time they get to the end of our conversation
Sure, I can summarize our conversation. We talked about the differences between body dysmorphia and gender dysphoria. Body dysmorphia is a mental health disorder characterized by obsessive thoughts about one's appearance and often involves a desire to change or alter one's body in some way. Gender dysphoria, on the other hand, is a condition where a person's gender identity does not match the sex they were assigned at birth.
We also discussed the different treatments for gender dysphoria, which can include hormone therapy, top surgery, and gender reassignment surgery. These treatments are often preceded by counseling and therapy to ensure that the individual is making an informed decision about their gender identity and expression.
We touched on the topic of transableism, which is a controversial concept where individuals feel that they are disabled and desire amputation of healthy limbs. We discussed the ethical considerations and potential implications of this concept.
We also talked about the role of parents and medical professionals in assigning a sex to a newborn baby and the potential for mistakes to occur. We discussed the importance of allowing individuals to express their gender identity and the importance of educating children about gender identity and expression.
Overall, our conversation touched on various complex and nuanced topics related to gender identity and expression, body image, and mental health. While we may have differing opinions on some aspects, we both emphasized the importance of compassion, understanding, and respect for individuals who are navigating these issues.
person1
thanks for the summary, could you also re-write it one more time as if it was two people talking to each other, i guess you could do person1 and person2 I want to see both of our personalities and ideas show through the conversation
Sure, here's a possible conversation-style rewrite:
Person 1: Hey there, I was wondering if you could help me understand the difference between body dysmorphia and gender dysphoria?
Person 2: Sure, I can try my best. Body dysmorphia is a condition where someone is preoccupied with perceived flaws or defects in their appearance, whereas gender dysphoria is a condition where someone's gender identity doesn't match their sex assigned at birth.
Person 1: Oh, I see. So what's the difference between someone with gender dysphoria who wants top surgery and someone with body dysmorphia who wants to have their legs amputated?
Person 2: Well, the difference lies in the reason behind their desire. For someone with gender dysphoria, top surgery is a way to alleviate their distress and help them align their physical appearance with their gender identity. On the other hand, someone with body dysmorphia may see amputation as a way to correct a perceived flaw in their body, but it wouldn't necessarily alleviate any distress they're experiencing.
Person 1: Hmm, I can see why that would be an important distinction. But what if someone with body dysmorphia wants top surgery to remove their breasts, for example? Wouldn't that be similar to someone with gender dysphoria?
Person 2: Yes, it can be tricky. But the difference still lies in the underlying reason behind their desire. For someone with gender dysphoria, top surgery is a necessary step in aligning their physical appearance with their gender identity. For someone with body dysmorphia, top surgery may be a way to correct a perceived flaw, but it wouldn't necessarily alleviate any distress related to their gender identity.
Person 1: I see what you mean. But do you think it's right for someone with body dysmorphia to undergo amputation surgery if it would alleviate their distress?
Person 2: That's a tough question. I think there are a lot of ethical considerations to take into account, particularly around informed consent and the potential for harm. But ultimately, it's important to prioritize the well-being and autonomy of the individual in question.
Person 1: Yeah, I can see why that would be a difficult issue to navigate. But what about the fact that some people argue that promoting acceptance of transgender people and gender-affirming surgeries could lead to children being encouraged to alter their bodies?
Person 2: I understand those concerns, but it's important to recognize that children who are questioning their gender identity often experience a lot of distress and confusion. Providing them with support and resources to explore their identity can be incredibly important for their well-being. And ultimately, any decisions around medical intervention would need to be made with careful consideration and in consultation with medical professionals.
Person 1: That makes sense. Thanks for helping me understand these issues better.
Person 2: Of course, happy to help! These are complex issues, but it's important to have conversations and try to understand each other's perspectives.
There is reasonable evidence that this article is machine-generated. Posting such content is considered fraud.
Fraud is discouraged by the community and may result in the account being Blacklisted.
Guide: Why and How People Abuse and Defraud
If you believe this comment is in error, please contact us in #appeals in Discord.
Duh check out the title :) 1/2 of it is. and Blacklisted from what? under what authority, Heck I'll make an account called Superhivewaterchers and try to extort your followers hahaha. j/k would not do anything like that.. would take to much time way from important things.
oh yea one more thing this whole " please contact us in #appeals in Discord." is horseshit too, that is like sending someone to a room with no cameras, everything transparent right?
"everything transparent"
Anyone user in Discord is able to use the screenshot function.
You asked in Discord for PM.
We don't allow private PM appeals as every appeal must be transparent in the public Discord channel.
I understand, transparent on a blockchain is a little different than a discord. Thanks for the reply.