My first thought was that it was a bad idea, and would be frustrating for new player. Then I thought about it a little more, and maybe each season it could reset. And also if you complete a bunch of achievements in a season you could earn the starter decks for the next season. Achievements could be in-game and also out of game like earning SPT writing blogs or using peakmonsters or delegating cards to a friends, using discord etc etc. I think you have a decent idea that would be worth exploring.
I think it would reduce the suction of the bots and increase card sales and rentals, it would be a win win win situation for all players. 🤑
also, the bots are stronger than new players because the bots calculate the best odds based on statistics and new players have no idea. this frustrates new players more than paying another 5 dollars in 2 months, i'm sure.
also it is called play to earn and not, play and get robbed by bots 😉