The object of this contest is to write a review and rate the contest story entries as shown here in @pibara's reminder post.
Here is the first story to review: Saviours of the Universe by @wrestlingdesires.
This is a wonderful short story that combines a variety of elements - human nature, science fiction, philosophy, and even some humor. It makes good use of dialog to paint the picture, but I did get lost a few times with the quickly changing characters and keeping up with who was speaking. Still, it was easy to follow the story. Also, I might suggest using fewer exclamation points. But these small items don't keep me from enjoying the story and the outcome. It is typical of the human race to be selfish when it came to the end and no solution could be found. The "test" aspect of the story was a nice twist in addition to the alien component.
The story was entertaining as well as thought-provoking, which is an added bonus while being entertained. The story was very well written and used imagery to a good advantage. I especially could relate to Mitchell's description of his boring daily life. And speaking of imagery, I liked the original artwork for the cover image.
In conclusion, I liked the story and give it a rating of 4.5 stars.
Here is the second story to review: On the Eve of Decay by @litguru.
This story would seem to come from a professional author. Very polished and well written. I love the take on the theme, to use a wizard and magic. Very clever how "the wizard" is never named, but Horatio as the assistant's name brings to mind another great magical assistant.
The imagery is excellent, you can feel the wizard's rage and see him smashing things in his lair. The explanation of the situation is easy to follow in spite of the technical issues. I also really liked the visual effects of the "grid of glittering fields" in the body of the story.
All during the story Horatio remains unconvinced of the wizard's plan and continues to advocate for further negotiations with the Bosums and the council. However, the wizard's mind is made up and he solves the problem for humanity himself by marching off with his fire wand.
In conclusion, the mix of science fiction and fantasy was a success. I am giving it a rating of 5.0 stars.
Here is the third story to review: Echo by @samsmith1971.
This story has an excellent take on the parameters that were presented as the basis. I loved the fact that we actually got to see the aftermath of the decision that was made. It was a clever move to send Dave, the AI, out into the universe to ensure that future civilizations could hear about our species and our sacrifice.
The research and technological aspects of the story made it very believable and realistic. You can see that a lot of thought and background went into the writing. The only criticism that I have is that the sentences are very long. I often had to go back and reread them to get their full value and meaning. But the fact remains that the story and the writing are good enough that I WANTED to go back and reread to make sure I got the full value!
It surprised me after the way the World Council debate seemed to go that the decision was indeed to sacrifice our exsistence. And it was saddening to learn that the decision was in vain, that the sacrifice had already been made by other civilizations and was therefore unnecessary for Earth to die. It gave the story a variety of emotions for the reader to experience.
In conclusion, this story was also a success and a good read. I am giving it a rating of 4.8 stars.
These three stories were all excellent and a pleasure to review, while being a nightmare to pick a winner! Good luck to all three authors, and to the person in charge of making this decision - I don't envy you!
Hive is a social blockchain where you can join communities, share and curate content and earn cryptocurrency that is growing in value. Sign up for an account at Sign up for Hive.
Very nice reviews @blueeyes8960, honest and to the point, nice job!
Thanks @crypt-skip, I hope it inspired you to read their stories, well worth the time!
The rewards earned on this comment will go directly to the person sharing the post on Twitter as long as they are registered with @poshtoken. Sign up at https://hiveposh.com.
A wonderful review. Thank you @blueeyes8960 for taking the time to write it. I love reading about the different elements that made an impact on the reading experience. The wizard's rage (and outrage) was indeed palpable when writing the story. No one will trifle with that cantankerous wizard. :)
It was my pleasure @litguru!
Thanks so much for the great review ♥️ Now I definitely know what to work on next :)
You are welcome @wrestlingdesires. I'm certainly no expert in writing or reviewing so I hope something I said was useful.
Believe me it was :) If you enjoy reading, you are enough of an expert :)
Thank you so much for taking the time to read our stories @blueeyes8960 :-) I really appreciate it and your reviews are considered and eloquent. I read the other entries myself and was blown away by the quality. I loved them! All the best in the review contest :-)
Thanks for the kind words, keep up the writing, I enjoyed your story immensely!
This post has received a 100.00% upvote from @fambalam! Join thealliance community to get whitelisted for delegation to this community service.