I replaced a ledger nano a month back, for the exact same reason.... screen not working anymore .... I replaced it with the same model, just becouse I bought a bunch of them way back and have them as reserve. ... I do use trezor as well, but that one is more BTC focused ... ergo less used, and it is still in great condition
The screens failing seems to be what happens to them all.
Pretty disappointing when they're marketed to people who store crypto long term...