June 13, 2018
Related Article:
Now is our chance to show the world that EOS is a governed blockchain
Background
With the mainnet launched, community attention has now moved towards the ongoing token voting for Block Producer candidates such as ourselves, EOS42, as we work to reach the 15% level that will activate the chain.
The Problem
It was Liam Wu, our Head of Community for China/South America at EOS42, who took it upon himself in the last 48hrs to start addressing the flood of reports coming in from across the world from people discovering they were unable to vote, and indeed that their private key was invalid and did not match their assigned address.
The Community Responds
This lead to Liam setting up a Telegram group, EOS 911 to bring together those from across the world effected by this problem.
Before long hundreds had joined this group including Block.one mighty moderator Sandwich, who invented the snapshot back up solution. What has been so amazing about the EOS community over the last two months is watching it collectively respond, and it did not disappoint again with many Block Producers including EOS Nation, EOS Dublin, EOS Cafe, eosDAC, EOS Rio, EOSYS and EOSNodeone stepping in to immediately give input to start discussing and working on a solution to save funds.
What Are We Doing To Secure Token Holder Funds?
Michael Yeates of eosDAC proposed that we code an Ethereum contract up that would enable token holders to prove they held the public and private keys to the associated Etheruem EOS ERC-20 tokens, and all those proven could then be frozen. This solution was being worked upon and discussed in the daily Block Producer early mainnet calls when we had some help and complexity.
Bitfinex and Huobi Step In
First Bitfinex and then Huobi came up with a proposal to speed up this period of slow climb in the mainnet token votes to the 15% mark, by consulting their customers and if approved temporarily staking the entire top 30 block producers to enable the chain to activate.
That immediately set off alarm bells within EOS42 as we began to consider the effective fast track of the chain activation and thieves making off with thousands of tokens. Today we called an emergency meeting, with Bitfinex CTO Paolo Ardoino immediately attending along with other Block Producers to talk through concerns and solutions:
Bitfinex were very concerned about any negative impact to token holders and offered their full support to prioritise working through a solution to protect the community. We're still waiting for a response from Huobi.
What Is Happening Next
An EOS42 developer has coded out the Ethereum contract, and with the help of EOS Rio are now busy testing it. Meanwhile Block Producers globally, in particular EOS Cannon in China, are continuing to pull together as many reported cases of registration fraud as possible. EOS Rio are going to assist this process further by fast building out a website to help the registration process.
The BP group discussed ways of freezing affected accounts immediately upon chain activation, and this will be the solution once these are registered in the coming hours with proof of Ethereum account ownership.
Was This An EOSIO Issue?
Not at all, unfortunately scammers setting up fake token registration portals have created this issue. However it is clear that some token holders were not cautious enough - including the owner of 550,000 EOS in a wallet impacted. This was unfortunately a natural risk and consequence from the need to register, now it is time for the community to rally around and prevent the thieves from getting away with it!
Social
Website
Telegram
Youtube
Bihu
EOS42 is an EOS Block Producer Candidate based in London, UK
Great work, guys.
this is one of the reasons people call EOS a scam which is sad.
dan could have made the process of contributing to the ICO simpler.
so sad to see people having to lose funds
brings bad omen to EOS
Although this is an unfortunate event now, and we are caught up in a quagmire, in the future we will look back at this and realize it was a necessary evil, and it will be seen as having generated a greater outcome in the long run for the EOS ecosystem and governance style as a whole.
wow
Nice how the community came together to take care of each other.
this initiative should become very visible to EOS fans in all the communities because knowing to have a fallback solution and not knowing wether your private key is compromised or not gives you two good reasons to do the vote!
I want to add EOS Amsterdam to the list of block producers, as they were present in the call and organised a video and form to help people whose keys were phished to report.
https://github.com/eosamsterdam/eos-keypair-check
Just for completeness. Great article!
Wow. Just wow. This is the new world, with decentralized investigations, decentralized collaboration of the eosPolice, eosJustice, eosBank and eosAsssetRecovery agency in action. This will definitely have caught the attention of the blockchain scammers. Its over thieves. An eosJail is next. Knowing these guys, somebody is probably already coding a contract for that! Kudos.
wow, that's an interesting read i love how that even though each community and BP are vying for votes, they are united to make things work.
How possible is it to retrieve some of the stolen eos? I heard mainnet becomes fully operational once 15% of the total has been staked. We're already at 10%. I'm sure once we get to 15%, the looters would sell off. how do they freeze it, if it isnt retrievable. or at least stake them to the top BPs?
I understand what you're doing and I think its great but to the uninitiated, your title reads like your saving up EOS token by doing registration scams. lol
Nice
What an excellent summary. Thanks eos42. This governance layer is just so brilliant that we will be studying it for years to come.
Oh, yeah...AirDrop! https://t.me/EOS_airdropbot/?id=3187761
This seems shady, so I'll flag it just in case.
In retrospect, that was the right call @apsu. Sorry for putting it on there. :/
Well I'm glad you don't seem like a scammer now, but Steemit (and other sites) are full of scammers so I'm trying to be more careful than carefree.
Hopefully the flag didn't cause a dent in your reputation.
no worries. I'm learning :)