Hmm but what if I know 60 really valuable users? I'm forced to leave some out of the vote... And what if I see 10 people spamming trash or whatever else? I'm forced to pick the 3 worse... I feel it has very limitations
Unless you tell me that's daily votes one can give
You can still support people via upvotes and still discourage spammers via downvotes.
Also, the numbers could be changed if it became a problem. We've talked about this with @ecoinstant and it would be an easy change to tweak the numbers.
What about a mix of the actual system and this? 1 only value made of this+actual system, just because one person can end up always with reputation 1 if he doesn't have any supporter and that's not very encouraging for onboarding
I think we would have to see how it works first. I suggested renaming the old system but keeping it. You should see the idea that @meno @buttcoins @ecoinstant and others came up with. A Hive flower where every petal is a different metric. It's a cool idea.