This is such a wonderful analysis of a fairy tale! This is one I heard growing up, I remember finding it funny then, how ridiculous he was. Going back to it as an adult, I can see how he seems petulant and unappreciative of all he accomplishes. The somewhat twisted tales of the brothers grimm always entertained me. I did particularly enjoy this one as a kid, but i think it probably was as you say, more to do with the scary aspect of it. The way he pursues being able to shiver, an instinctive reaction someone has very little control over, it's almost like he makes it so it won't ever happen. By being so focused on not being able to shiver, he isn't present enough in any situation to have that natural experience. I love your alternative princess with a bucket of fish ending, that made me giggle!
I am sincerely appreciative of how well referenced this dive into a fairy tale is. It's really interesting to think about how different fairy tales rise and fall in popularity, and how that must in some way reflect differing attitudes. Really enjoyed this!
What an interesting view of the problem. It has happened to everybody, I think, we go after something for so long and it turns out it was there right before us. In this case he had lots of opportunities, but he missed them all. Perhaps understanding that helps the story become more popular :D
Thanks for the visit, @laetalis-laetitia!