I built @lorkus to compete at the top of Modern. My scholar gets more out of that deck than I can, and I get to see what the collection can do in the hands of a better player. He gets to compete with cards he didn’t have to spend years collecting. I want more of those deals in Splinterlands. They give skilled people a way into Champion and give the rest of us more good players to face.
Every time we make it harder to make that deal, we ask the owner to accept a smaller return or the player to put in the same hours for less. Some will do it. Others will have better things to do. That’s what I think we stand to lose when another proposal starts from the premise that scholars are taking too much.
@chiboulette brought up a scholar taking 12% of Champion rewards in this comment. I own one of the decks behind that number. Here’s what the season looked like from my side.
In Season 194, the same pilot played 1,999 matches and won 1,496 across @housewifeftw, @kesryn and @lorkus. Those decks earned 73,614.201 SPS, or 12% of the available Champion pool. At a 50/50 split, that’s 36,807 SPS for the pilot and 36,807 SPS for the owners combined. The three accounts had 21.81 million SPS staked when I checked after the season. After accounting for SPS delegated in and out, 11.09 million SPS counted toward their reward multipliers. Getting to the point where someone wants to play 646 matches on @lorkus took a lot of collecting. The pilot still had to win 479 of them.
The Season 194 leaderboard shows where each deck finished. The Modern payout rules explain how the bracket payout is calculated.

What a cut costs the people who play
My first question about going back to 2% is where the clipped SPS goes. Holding the Season 194 results and pool fixed, these owners would give up about 18,404 SPS combined, and the pilot would give up the same amount. If that buys a deeper, more competitive field, show me how. I’m willing to consider a cut to my deck’s earnings if the proposal can make that case.
| Per-account cap | Gross across three decks | Pilot at 50% | Owners at 50%, combined |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4%, actual gross | 73,614 SPS | 36,807 SPS | 36,807 SPS |
| 3%, modeled | 55,211 SPS | 27,605 SPS | 27,605 SPS |
| 2%, modeled | 36,807 SPS | 18,404 SPS | 18,404 SPS |
A two-deck limit cuts the pilot’s pay by a third at the same split. In this example, it falls from 36,807 SPS to 24,538 SPS. One owner has to find another pilot, play the deck themselves, or let it sit.
Half the rewards is already a lot to give up as an owner. As the rewards on my deck have fallen, giving the scholar a meaningful share is how I make it worth his time to play hundreds of matches. There’s only so much more I can give up before the deal stops making sense for me, too. If we cut a third of what a scholar can earn, we should expect some of them to play less. Champion needs those people in the queue.
The team raised the payout cap from 2% to 4% for the second October season. Three decks is what this pilot played. The published Modern Champion rule permits one active account at a time with a five-minute switching wait.

Wild has bots. Modern has scholars.
A scholar fills the same hole in Modern that a bot service fills in Wild: the owner wants the deck played, and someone else takes the matches. I want those matches in Modern played by people. The rules already make a Champion pilot finish one account’s battle and wait five minutes before starting on another. A proposal to limit how many owners they can play for would add another constraint to a job that already takes hundreds of matches a deck.
In those same 15 days, XBOT collected 3.31 times the pay this pilot would have earned at a 50/50 split. Archmage collected 2.20 times. When we debate whether a human can play for three owners, I think it matters that a Wild service can earn fees from hundreds.
| Service | Payer accounts | Executed fees | Share of all settled Wild claims |
|---|---|---|---|
| XBOT | 575 | 121,877.784 SPS | 10.99% |
| Archmage | 440 | 80,921.391 SPS | 7.30% |
| Combined | 993 | 202,799.175 SPS | 18.29% |
Wild settled 1,108,659.685 SPS in the window. I counted fees paid to @splinterbank for XBOT and @archmage.billing for Archmage. The combined payer count removes the 22 accounts that paid both. XBOT reward-share terms · Archmage FAQ · Example executed receipt

Discrimination against scholars
@shadecroat’s proposal to limit scholars to two accounts owned by others failed on September 2. The ownership exemption is why I think it was a bad idea. It would have let me play three Champion decks if I owned all three. If three owners hired the same player to run those decks, that player would have to give one up. I’d see the same person in the same three places on the leaderboard either way. The player who can afford to buy the cards gets to keep competing on all three decks.
That’s discrimination against scholars, and it’s a pattern I’m tired of seeing. A scholar has a good season, and the conversation turns to how many decks we’ll let them play and how much those decks should earn. Under that proposal, someone wealthy enough to build several top decks could keep all their entries. A player skilled enough to earn the trust of several owners would have to turn work down. Collectors like me would have fewer choices about who plays our cards. I want a game where getting good opens doors, especially if you can’t buy your way into a Champion deck.
I understand wanting to see more names at the top of Modern. I’d try @seattlea’s idea of showing each player’s best finish, using the same rule for everyone. That would give us a better answer to who had the best season without taking a cut out of someone’s deck.
There’s a better argument for lowering the cap: more players might push for Champion if they can earn a worthwhile payout. I’d take that seriously. @warrentrx’s proposal asks how many entrants a bracket should need to unlock its full pool. If the idea is to cut the cap as well, tell the players just outside the top spots how much more they’d earn. Then see if more of them come back to compete next season.
We’ve already seen who takes the cut
In Season 193, the same three decks first received 38,744 SPS. Then the game credited them another 38,744 SPS to bring the payout up to 4%. Same decks, same matches, double the payout. At a 50/50 split, both the pilot and the owners went from 19,372 SPS to 38,744 SPS.
Over that same season, XBOT collected 134,612 SPS in Wild fees and Archmage collected 91,802 SPS. The cap applied to Modern bracket winnings. At 4%, XBOT’s fees were about 3.5 times what the pilot would take home. At 2%, they were about 7 times. Archmage went from 2.4 times to 4.7 times. The lower cap cut the SPS we had to split in Modern. It left those Wild fees untouched.

Apply 2% to Season 194 and the pilot again loses half: 36,807 SPS becomes 18,404 SPS, with the owners taking the same cut. That’s the effect of a payout cap that applies across Champion. The failed two-account proposal went further: it singled out people playing for other owners.
I want good players to get more chances to compete in Modern. Scholars already put in the matches, and they give collectors like me a reason to keep building decks that can compete at the top. A rule that takes half their pay, or takes away the decks they can play, needs to earn its place. Show me who benefits and why the game is better with fewer opportunities for the people playing it by hand.
For the curious
On SplinterTools, you can look up season payouts, explore SPS data, and review battles and lineups.
I agree that we shouldn't discriminate against scholars. Nice post Lorkus