I think we'll have to try Bermuda. A few people I know say they don't like St. Thomas because it's too "gritty" but that's an aspect of it we enjoy. There's a vibrant local culture, not just tourism. St. John is beautiful but has a completely different feel, almost like a gated community, homogenous.
Thanks for the gorgeous photos!
You are absolutely correct! I cannot believe that 98% of people never walk into the culture. It's not in the tourist spots, perhaps a touch of what it is like, but, if you want to really meet the culture, you have to walk into their world. I have been fascinated by it. We are the ones that have spoiled the culture with our tourism and cruise ships. :) Although, it does bring money to the island, many times the people of the island don't see the benefits. Many of those companies are not from there and don't spend the money there.
Each and every country down there has a different flavor and the vibe always invites a happy, vibrant feeling. In Curacao, we had a congo line all through the downtown. It was so fun!!
If they want gritty, Haiti is truly what they are looking for.
I agree with your St. John accessment. That is truly what they want. :))