Part 4/8:
Isaac recognizes the importance of representation in modern media, arguing that previously underrepresented groups should indeed find their place within established narratives. However, he argues that the means of making these changes—especially when they forcefully alter established characters—may lead to backlash among fans. He cites a contrasting example with the characters from Amazon’s adaptations, maintaining that fidelity to Tolkien’s legacy should remain paramount, regardless of current social dynamics.
The merit of Tolkien's storytelling lies in its intrinsic focus on character over race. The tales showcase the moral fiber of individuals without a secondary focus on racial characteristics, which should be honored in adaptations aiming for authenticity.