Part 4/6:
Despite the achievement of Allen, an equally notable topic discussed was the absence of two-time Super Bowl MVP Eli Manning from the Hall of Fame class of 2025. Manning’s polarizing candidacy stirs debate among fans and sports analysts alike. While many believe he should have secured a first-ballot Hall of Fame spot due to his historic postseason performances—particularly against the New England Patriots—others remain unconvinced, pointing to his lack of All-Pro selections and frequently lower passer rating stats compared to contemporaries.
Consensus seems to indicate that Manning is destined for the Hall of Fame eventually, but the conclusion of discussions around his first-year eligibility highlighted the ongoing debates about quarterback criteria.