Part 5/7:
The debate isn't solely one-sided. Critics of Manning’s Hall of Fame aspirations cite his regular-season performance as a substantial concern. As Manning enters his first year of eligibility, some fans argue that he does not meet the statistical threshold for enshrinement based on regular season play alone. Comparisons to other players, such as Philip Rivers and Terrell Davis, spotlight the contention regarding what makes a player “Hall of Fame worthy.” While Rivers performed consistently during the regular season, Manning's true legacy is deeply intertwined with his postseason heroics.