Part 12/13:
Final Verdict: A Middle Ground, Not Worth Your Time
Most critics agree that High Guardian Spice is neither the terrible train wreck some predicted nor the progressive masterpiece many fans hoped for. It’s a middling series—about a 2.5 to 3-star rating—lacking the execution, storytelling, and cohesion to justify the hype or justify inclusion in a platform known for quality anime.
It feels more like a show aimed at a specific niche: middle school kids, shippers, and viewers interested in superficial diversity messaging. For casual viewers or fans of authentic anime, it’s best avoided. For those curious about the backlash or the controversy surrounding modern animated projects, it offers some insights but ultimately leaves more questions than answers about the industry’s direction.