Part 8/13:
The Issue of Ed and Cultural Representation
Another contentious point is the character Ed, a fan-favorite whose enigmatic and gender-fluid nature contributed to the anime’s unique identity. The concerns are that the show might "age up" Ed for live-action adaptation, potentially stripping away the character's originality and appeal.
More broadly, there’s notable dissatisfaction over the lack of Japanese talent involved in the production. Critics ask why Japanese creators or consultants are not part of the project, given the series’ cultural roots. The absence signifies a disconnect—another sign of the adaptation's dubious authenticity.