Part 9/12:
The debate isn’t unique to Batwoman. Historically, casting decisions for marginalized characters have often become litmus tests for cultural attitudes towards race and sexuality. Guests and commentators referenced past controversies, recalling how Ruby Rose’s casting was also contentious — with some claiming she wasn't "gay enough" or "Jewish enough," revealing how identity politics shape casting choices severely.
This pattern underscores a broader societal tension: balancing representation without stereotypes, respecting individual agency while addressing historical prejudices, and understanding that acting involves embodying complex characters that often diverge from the actor's personal identity.