Part 6/12:
Reflecting on Alonso’s previous negotiations, the picture appears less promising. He turned down a $158 million offer roughly two years ago, reportedly seeking $200 million or more. Critics argue that Alonso’s long-term demands could be driven by high expectations and a desire for security, but they also risk alienating potential suitors who are wary of his defensive liabilities and aging curve.
The perception is further complicated by Alonso’s reputation as a "one-dimensional slugger." While his power numbers are elite—he lead the league in home runs and clutch hitting—his defense and speed have been called into question. This dichotomy has caused many fans and analysts to wonder whether Alonso's demands are realistic or simply a negotiation tactic.