Part 9/12:
The hosts also explored the concept of Alonso as a designated hitter—once he transitions away from defense—potentially increasing his offensive value and contract appeal. Still, they acknowledged that at some point, age and decline will diminish those numbers, and the risk of overpaying in Alonso’s late 30s could be detrimental.
Cultural and Organizational Factors
The discussion wasn’t solely about numbers. The hosts expressed a deep affection for Alonso, emphasizing his importance as a franchise and the cultural fit he represents. They argued that the Mets should aim for a "fair deal", with some proposing a five-year, $125 million contract as an optimal outcome, balancing Alonso’s requested value and the team’s strategic interests.