Part 4/7:
The critique extends beyond the individual story to the media's overall approach. Critics argue that Gilbert's social and economic status may contribute to the leniency she receives. If the person involved in such a serious crime were less privileged or of a different ethnicity, the narrative—and possibly the consequences—might be entirely different.
The New York Times featured a profile of Gilbert published on September 5th, with a headshot that the critic describes as a "glamour shot." The portrayal is seen as reflecting the image of a glamorous figure, rather than acknowledging her darker aspects that have long been apparent to astute followers.