Part 10/13:
Beyond storytelling choices, the performance of Bella Ramsey as Ellie is heavily criticized. Her portrayal is seen as lacking depth, with some viewers describing her as smug or arrogant, further disengaging audiences from the character. The portrayal of Ellie’s emotional intensity is deemed superficial, making it hard for fans to empathize with her.
Similarly, in the series, Ellie’s physical fights are exaggerated—beyond realistic human capabilities—such as her taking on much larger opponents with ease. Critics argue that such scenes break immersion and point to a lack of consistency in characterization, especially considering Bella Ramsey’s petite stature compared to the muscular, imposing depictions of Abby or the fight scenes.