Part 2/11:
As it turns out, those initial fears were justified—All's Fair is overwhelmingly considered a monumental failure. Critical reception has been nearly universal in its harshness. Rotten Tomatoes currently awards the show a dismal 0% approval rating based on 17 reviews, with a critic describing it as potentially the worst TV drama ever. A single positive review exists, pushing the score slightly up to 6%, but this minor bump does little to mask the overall consensus: the show is a disastrous misstep.