Part 2/11:
The initial reviews for Season 4 tell a stark story: critics give it around 55%, and fan scores on Rotten Tomatoes hover at a dismal 19%. These figures are just starting points; they can fluctuate, but the downward trend is clear. This sharp decline from previous seasons signals a disconnect between the show's direction and audience expectations.
The Root of Discontent: Departure of Henry Cavill and Lore Desecration
Many fans point to the departure of Henry Cavill as a pivotal moment that exposed the show's underlying issues. Cavill's Geralt was lauded for his gruff charm and fidelity to the beloved source material— the books and video games. When he left, it became apparent that the series had shifted focus, prioritizing activist-driven narratives over faithful storytelling.