Part 5/10:
A core issue with The American Society of Magical Negroes was its failure to deliver effective satire. True satire relies on sharp wit, exaggeration, and humor—elements sorely lacking in this film. Instead, it presented itself as a serious social commentary, with actors and creators apparently convinced of its profundity when, in reality, it came off as preachy and disconnected from actual lived experiences. The result was a movie that barely elicited a chuckle and left audiences feeling both uncomfortable and unimpressed.