Part 8/9:
A Critique of Identity Politics
The overarching critique from critics and disappointed fans centers around the series' focus on identity politics. The casting of Sauron as a person of color, for example, is seen as an obvious move to appear more diverse rather than faithful to Tolkien’s descriptions. Critics argue that this undermines the story's authenticity and disrespects its global, multicultural audience.
The narrative is viewed as being "raped and pillaged," with many feeling that Amazon is more interested in pushing a woke agenda than respecting the integrity of Tolkien's universe. The criticism emphasizes that The Lord of the Rings has a universal appeal precisely because it transcends race and politics, offering a timeless story loved worldwide.