Part 3/11:
This dissonance has manifested in a fierce backlash, with fans vocally criticizing the show’s storytelling choices, character portrayals, and perceived racial swapping—elements that have become central to the controversy. Initially, Amazon attempted to deflect criticism by framing detractors as racist, claiming that negative reactions were rooted in racial bias rather than valid critique. This strategy, however, appears to be faltering as mounting evidence suggests the dissatisfaction is rooted in genuine concerns about the show's fidelity to Tolkien’s universe.