Part 8/10:
Such contradictions raise fundamental questions about the show's direction. If the stories and characters are truly meant to be timeless, why alter or add elements that were not in Tolkien's original writings? Critics argue that these changes undermine the very core of Tolkien’s craftsmanship and betray the detailed universe he built.
The Broader Cultural Debate
The controversy over The Rings of Power encapsulates a wider cultural debate about adapting classic stories for modern audiences. Purists argue that faithfulness to the source material is crucial to preserve its integrity and legacy. Others contend that adaptations should evolve and reflect contemporary diversity and social values.