Part 5/9:
The core criticism centers on the apparent inconsistency: while claiming victimhood and exclusion, initiatives like Project Stardust advocate for an exclusive, women-only space within Star Wars fandom. This contradiction is highlighted by the plans for a women of color segment, which many see as emblematic of identity-based division rather than genuine inclusivity.
Ryan emphasizes that race and gender are irrelevant in the context of fandom. The argument is that nobody has ever been barred from participating in Star Wars discussions due to their gender or race—these are constructs pushed by those seeking to create victim narratives.