Part 6/9:
For instance, Tassie claimed Ghost of Tsushima achieved the highest user score of any game in its generation, but Ryan demonstrates that this is only true when only recent reviews or specific platforms are considered. When broader, all-time reviews are examined—such as the PC or Switch versions—the game’s score is different, and other titles like Cry Star or Superliminal might surpass Tsushima’s scores in niche categories. Ryan underscores that the game’s core PS4 user rating remains an impressive 9.3 with thousands of reviews, strongly supporting its fan popularity.
Ryan criticizes Tassie for "forgetting" key data points—such as the number of reviews and the actual comparisons—in his analyses, which can lead to misleading conclusions about the game's standing.