Part 6/9:
Many critics have accused her of avoiding accountability regarding the race swap, suggesting that she could have intervened before the controversy erupted. Instead, Rowling seems to be asserting her principled stance on free speech and employer discretion, though this approach has done little to quell fan outrage.
The Broader Cultural and Industry Context
The controversy is not solely about casting; it underscores the ongoing clashes between traditional fan expectations and Hollywood’s evolving approach to diversity and representation. Fans who grew up with the Harry Potter universe often view such changes as eroding the authenticity of beloved characters. Others argue that race swapping is a necessary step toward inclusivity, though this debate remains heated.