Part 3/5:
The Criticism and Fan Reactions
The commentary reflects a mix of bewilderment and critique towards Carpenter's approach. The conversation hints at her using shock tactics, such as implying violence or death in her videos, to stand out in a crowded music landscape. Critics accuse her of recycling a controversial shtick—involving themes of destruction and misanthropy—without offering something new or thoughtful.
One person in the discussion remarks on her acting as if critics are scandalized by her, calling her critics "pearl clutchers." This suggests she is aware of the provocative nature of her art and perhaps even plays into it intentionally to appease her rebellious audience.