That's right and it's baffling why Rondon initiated the idea and he may have his reasons which he mentioned he will share via a post.
What would be good is to use the reward pool so it helps to add value to Hive, such as rewards based on engagement as well as author and curation, and also a multiplier reward for those who stake and don't withdraw.
I totally support this. It would definitely spur more participation and perhaps encourage those who do not see a long-term vision for Hive.