There were times when 100% HP was viewed as a loyality statement and 50/50 HP/HBD as a mild cash grab. The view has switched recently but it is nothing more significant than yellow becoming the trendy color for the next few months replacing green.
The real value of the choice is the monetary incentive to pick printing/not printing new HBD according to actual tokenomics need. Post payout is just the tactics, then you can excercise your strategy using HIVE/HBD market (or conversions) and Power Up/Down button.