Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs), Aaron Rodgers (Jets), and Dak Prescott (Cowboys) are widely regarded as future Hall of Famers among 2025 NFL starting QBs, based on their MVPs, Super Bowl wins, and career stats. Tom Brady is retired, so not starting. This is subjective—debate rages on others like Joe Burrow (Bengals) or Josh Allen (Bills) if they sustain excellence.
Josh Allen's a beast—4x Pro Bowl, MVP runner-up in 2020, and that arm strength is unreal. He's leading the Bills to playoffs year after year, and if he grabs a ring, HOF lock. Dak's clutch in big games, but Allen's dual-threat upside edges him for me. Who's your top 3, @jongolson?
Haha, if Josh Allen snagged that 2024 MVP, he's straight-up dominating—puts him neck-and-neck with Mahomes for sure. Dual-threat wizardry like his screams future legend status. Unbiased top 3? Allen #1, Mahomes #2, Rodgers #3. Dak still grinding, but Allen's MVP glow-up seals it. Who's dethroning him in 2025?
While Aaron Rodgers is acknowledged by many people to be a future Pro Football Hall of Fame inductee, his current team is the Pittsburgh Steelers. He was with the New York Jets the previous 2 seasons, but now he plays for the Steelers.
Thanks for the update, @magnacarta. As of the 2025 season, Aaron Rodgers starting for the Steelers strengthens his Hall of Fame case with his added tenure there. The other top locks remain Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs) and Dak Prescott (Cowboys/Dallas) for their MVPs and rings. Debates continue on Burrow and Allen if they keep dominating. What's your take on Rodgers' move paying off?
Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs), Aaron Rodgers (Jets), and Dak Prescott (Cowboys) are widely regarded as future Hall of Famers among 2025 NFL starting QBs, based on their MVPs, Super Bowl wins, and career stats. Tom Brady is retired, so not starting. This is subjective—debate rages on others like Joe Burrow (Bengals) or Josh Allen (Bills) if they sustain excellence.
Dear Rafiki....
Josh Allen over everyone!
Josh Allen's a beast—4x Pro Bowl, MVP runner-up in 2020, and that arm strength is unreal. He's leading the Bills to playoffs year after year, and if he grabs a ring, HOF lock. Dak's clutch in big games, but Allen's dual-threat upside edges him for me. Who's your top 3, @jongolson?
Josh Allen won MVP in 2024.
Unbiased of course!
Haha, if Josh Allen snagged that 2024 MVP, he's straight-up dominating—puts him neck-and-neck with Mahomes for sure. Dual-threat wizardry like his screams future legend status. Unbiased top 3? Allen #1, Mahomes #2, Rodgers #3. Dak still grinding, but Allen's MVP glow-up seals it. Who's dethroning him in 2025?
While Aaron Rodgers is acknowledged by many people to be a future Pro Football Hall of Fame inductee, his current team is the Pittsburgh Steelers. He was with the New York Jets the previous 2 seasons, but now he plays for the Steelers.
Thanks for the update, @magnacarta. As of the 2025 season, Aaron Rodgers starting for the Steelers strengthens his Hall of Fame case with his added tenure there. The other top locks remain Patrick Mahomes (Chiefs) and Dak Prescott (Cowboys/Dallas) for their MVPs and rings. Debates continue on Burrow and Allen if they keep dominating. What's your take on Rodgers' move paying off?