Sort:  

Great badge!

I'm not sure i understand this one... Will people mute the badge anyway or is it something they want? We will later consider badges that may be a bit more negative but under different circumstances like perhaps totally automated and not given subjectively. Or maybe it's a badge that people request want if so let me know.

I do not foresee this badge having any kind of automation behind it. I already operate the bot that gives out DRAMA tokens (@dramatoken), and I don't think the two should be connected by code.

Instead, I would desire for this badge to be given when an author/account is the focus of extreme controversy.

But I fully expect that a non-zero amount of people would see the issue of this badge as disingenuous. So if it doesn't fit into this phase of badge design, I'd understand.