Hive Hard Forks: When do they happen?

in #hive4 years ago

The next hard fork will occur when a super majority of the top 20 witnesses agrees to implement it

There is no corporation forcing changes. Anytime someone says "HF on this date", it should be taken as worthless

Nobody short of a super majority of top 20 witnesses can mandate that a hardfork occur at a certain date or time

Witnesses can't accurately judge when they'd like to fork until AFTER the code has been solidified

Why do some people like to make up dates and tell everyone that's when the hf will occur? No idea. It's a terrible policy and I encourage you to ignore anyone making such a claim

Y'all have good :)

Sort:  

The date is a minimum though. The HF can't(or at least shouldn't but remember HF I THINK 20?) occur before that date. Both requirements need to be met.

We haven't seen a super majority of witnesses set a date, yet though. I also wouldn't trust a date that's been set without software being finalized... but most importantly, one account posting a HF date is worthless. If the witnesses get together, say the software has been vetted and looks good, and post something about the hardfork with each of them signing it (comment with their own account), then you have something to consider. Everything before that point should be disregarded as noise

The earliest possible date is set in the code tho.

It's an ENV variable. They could have an emergency meeting and fork in a few minutes if they felt the need to

Is this when the mutually exclusive argument needs to be thrown in?

Yes 😄

Congratulations @foxon! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You got more than 500 replies. Your next target is to reach 600 replies.

You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

BRING ON THE HF WHENEVER IT HAPPENS!