You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Hive Keychain Proposal 3 (DHF)

in #hive3 years ago

For a while I found the multitude of key chain extensions annoying. Then I found WhaleVault which can handle 15 different Steem like chains including hive.

image.png

I don't understand why every Steem like chain insists on creating their own keychain extension. For me this sounds like a pure vanity project as a universal keychain solution exists. It would be much more efficient to join the WhaleVault effort instead of wasting developer time on creating yet-another-keychain-extension without added value to the end user.

Quite the opposite: If you have accounts at multiple chains having to install a keychain-extension for all of them is just annoying.

Sort:  

On one hand, yes you are right, collaboration could benefit everyone. But on the other hand, centralization vs decentralization. If there are multiple options, then we have choices if one goes bad.

That's cute when someone write without knowing what they are talking about.
The project you are mentioning is a clone based on my work. So without this 'vanity project', the one you use wouldn't even exist.

Fair enough. But as often: The clone is better the the original as it offers features the original doesn't offer. Namely support for multiple chains.

The only thing that changes is the direction: Why didn't you merge multi chain support back into your project? WhaleVault is available on Github so that shouldn't be impossible.

Being the original project and being a vanity project doesn't exclude each other. It's still a vanity if you don't add useful features for personal reasons.

I don't know the background but sounds like if you want want this whalevault wallet to get better you should hope that hive keychain gets funding since they are apt to use this code base.

Anyway what is the website or profile link of the group creating whalevault... because trust is a big part of being willing to install an extension and there is so far no reason to have that trust in this unknown wallet.

You do you but Whalevault is not even opensource, so 1) I couldn't merge it if I wanted to, 2) you use it at your own peril since nobody can make sure no code is added with malicious intentions.
They do have a github page for reference :
https://github.com/alexpmorris/whalevault
But there's nothing there except a license and a README.

They cloned two years ago so I'm pretty sure we re way ahead in terms of features. That's being said, indeed we don't plan on supporting other chains.
First, Hive Hard Forked couple of times and there are features which are not supported by other chains. Second, except from you, we've never really got any demand for this.