Sort:  

HiveList store.

I WOULD CHOOSE OPTION #1.

It would look like Kijiji or Gum Tree if sales and services were together.

I rationalized a services marketplace coexisting with a commodities marketplace, this would reflect the image shared by mainstream domains like https://kijiji.ca and https://gumtree.com

I would infer that users would be familiar from this type of format and layout to a web page.

I don't want to seeing advertisements in my feed everytime a new SKU is added.

In option 2, I see the potential for spam, the comment field already has the same smart features that a full form has. Waivio is already working on Hive as a Utility for Businesses. They only post SKU's, product additions, and price adjustments in the comments.

I would downvote posts that are abusing the main feed instead of using comments on previous posts for the smart contract at their merchant point of sale. Waivio has already resolved this issue with spam on the feed, and you're competitors for the role as Hives commerce platform.

I do not want to see uninformed new users spamming the feeds because they don't understand that the comment field is supposed to be used for meticulous updates like price adjustments and SKU changes.

Well that’s not what I am talking about but thanks for your input and vote.

I had never heard of those sites before so didn’t know what you were talking about, lol. Gotcha.

They are outdated and your new vision would probably be better than their current sites.

A latter concern of mine, that is not yet logical or tangible to worry about, is users milking the reward pool to increase the bottom line of their business with upvotes for SKU and prices changes. Meticulous contracts DO NOT BELONG IN THE MAIN FEED. They are not meaningful to other users, only the ones who are trying to increase their bottom line with the rewards pool.

None of that you are talking about would be on chain anyway. What I mean about advertising their services is just posting their link to Hivelist the same way they would now... You read way too far into things man... all I wanted was a simple vote.

Going over details many times for memorization is something I tend to do a bit too much.

I support your platform, just wasn't sure what part I should elaborate on.

I like the many thoughts you put into this. While I understand that @thelogicaldude didn't reach a stage where this conversation becomes relevant, comments like these should still be encouraged because they help reach conclusions long-term.

I have been on a tirade for the last year, since lockdown all the extra time I have spent being critical on here has come to a point that I should start contributing more, but I am as much as I can in the sense of liquidity and market analysis.

The way I overthrowing the numbers has the interest of local game developers who see a potential on this platform for some cool integrations of decentralized in gane economies.