I've been reading this post and its comments for quite some time. Very in-depth discussions. I can't say I have a full understanding of this whole thing (although I believe I have a vague understanding of most of this). Reasonably, I won't offer an opinion based on my limited knowledge.
However, I wanted to say thank you for your post and thank you to everyone in the discussion for shedding a lot of light on this topic through amicable debate.
Cheers.