You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: So, you're an anarchist?

in #philosophy7 years ago

How can Anarchy Exist within a State? Either people are sovereign or the state is sovereign and if the State is sovereign the use of force can be applied against its shareholders by the State.

The weight brothers learned and solved the physics of a physical problem. They didn't resolve an Oxymoron.

Sort:  

You had more than one argument against Anarchy. I wasn't addressing your "How can Anarchy exist within a State" question by bringing up the Wright Brothers. I was addressing your assertion that no current or past working model means anything about whether an idea can become reality. I think you are smart enough that you knew that but are being dodgy. Is that what they call intellectual dishonesty?

Anarchy is an Idea I gave up in Middle School after having my lunch stolen too many times. Human nature my friend..... Human Nature.

Well, that explains a lot. LOL

You were robbed, and now you want to rob others. Brilliant!

Where is anarchy, humans interacting with no need of outside rulership, in the world?

It is everywhere! Go to a crowded place, sit down, and watch. That's not too much to ask, right?

Now what do you see? You will see a VAST majority of people being peaceful and interacting voluntarily. They are not doing it because of laws either. They are doing it because that's the norm. That's anarchism.

Most people do not steal other children's lunch money. The children that do steal grow up to steal. They tend to like positions that give them lots of power, control, and the protection of double standards too.

No you're confused. I'm not a communist. I don't want to rob anyone. But if you're talking about Taxation that's simply payment of a debt for maintaining jurisdiction over us both. Voluntarily by way of representation in congress.

That's funny. If you're taking something from me by force, it is theft. Call it "payment of a debt" if you wish, but it is theft.

It wasn't yours to begin with.