Sounds great, except the announcement of downvotes for everything possible. Unfortunately, many people now associate downvotes with very arbitrary or inappropriate behaviour. To punish customers (who will probably never show up again) by taking some cents away might be appropriate but certainly not useful.
Of course, I have no idea what's your plan.
I have only observed the very clumsy behavior of various Tribe owners who have been downvoting their own future.
I believe the majority who may not use the Tag properly will even be pleased about an enlightening comment.
Professional marketing would be that in any case.
I wish you much success and for myself this Tribe seems to be an interesting alternative.
Downvotes are just as much a part of the eco-system as Upvotes I'm not sure how anyone can argue the contrary?
I was in the same boat as you early on about downvotes but then realized what an important role they played.
You're absolutely right. Your comment and mine don't contradict each other.
After all, I'm not saying that there can be no downvotes, you have to use it with care.
If not it has a great destructive power.
How many upvotes does someone need to psychologically compensate one downvote?
Certainly a lot.
Sure, DV should come with care no disagreement there.
Misplaced/misused tags would be a great example of how to use a downvote.
Someone might get a DV one day, and many UV the next with no DV or a bit of both. I don't think it will discourage anyone ( or, shouldn't). They just need to learn how the Steem blockchain as a tool is used as w/ anything new.
To borrow a line from Spider-Man's Uncle Ben "With great power, comes great responsibility."
If people are genuine, they will generally be receptive to communication regarding anything that is frowned upon. If that communication falls on deaf ears or is essentially ignored, then those individuals are probably not that interested in being part of the community anyway