The Investor's Dilemma: The difference between an Investor and Gambler

in #riskmanagement5 years ago (edited)

I was once asked, what is the difference between gambling and investing as it relates to financial markets. At the time I gave some generic answer but if I am to be honest with myself that question requires deep thought and analysis. As with most things of financial matters, the topic of investing is subtle and rigorous and requires deep critical analysis. As with most things of financial matters, the topic of investing is subtle and rigorous and critical analysis. In this blog post I will attempt to broach a key concept of investing; minimizing risk. In my experience, the difference between an investor and a gambler, is that an investor is one who considers and manages risk successfully.

For which of you, intending to build a tower, sitteth not down first, and counteth the cost, whether he have sufficient to finish it? - Jesus, Luke 14:28

It is amazing to witness many people who don’t really challenge their ideas and implement rigorous self analysis. In the financial world this is a fatal mistake that investors make. I am astonished at how many investors simply don’t understand the investments that they make. I believe this is because people are not taught how to think like an investor. All too often, people get into investments with the lack of information needed to make sounds decisions. Furthermore, many lack the discipline and patience to make good investment.

“Risk comes from not knowing what you are doing” - Warren Buffett

The cornerstone principle that separates an investor from a gambler is that an investor top priority is to minimize his/her losses. In order words, an investors looks for ways to maximize his minimum return! This is in contrast to a gambler who’s mindset is focused on maximizing his overall returns (focus only on the upside) but ignores (or is ignorant) to the downside risk. Now to many this may sound simple but it is a core principle that even many professional investors (myself included) at times forget and often pay dearly for it.

Pulling out the Probability Tool Box

Let’s say we place a hypothetical bet with a bookie on an single NFL game (let’s say the Dallas Cowboys vs. New York Giants), we place a $500 bet on the New York Giants with a bookie. We receive a 1000 to 1 odds. In this hypothetical wager; if the Giants lose then we walk away with $500,000 but if we lose then we are out of $500. In our scenario, let’s say that the Giants are winning 35-31 with 6 minutes left in the 4th quarter. We are super excited of the possibility of winning $499,500 in profits!

The Call

Then your bookie calls with an interesting offer. He offers to buy you out of your bet and guarantees you a payout of $150,000. Although you are guarantee a nice payout you will lose out in receiving $500,000 if the Giants win. However if the Cowboys pull off a come back in the last 6 minutes of the game we lose our $500 and get nothing. So, what do we do?

Again, this is all theoretical and in real life other factors and assumptions must be considered. Other factors to consider in real-life would be:

• What are the probability that the Cowboys will mount a comeback the last 6 minutes of the game?
• Are there any key injuries on both sides?
• Are the Giants playing at home or away?
• Are their weather conditions to factor in?

That being said, what is the best choice to make in this scenario? The obvious choice (on paper) is to take the buyout and guarantee $150,000 return.

The reason being is that initially we were living life on the edge because the odds (1000 to 1) suggests that the Giants have a .001 chance of winning the game. Although it is tempting with 6 minutes left in the game to gamble it all and decline the guarantee $150,000. The alternative is to pray and wish that the Giants can keep the lead for next grueling 6 more minutes.

Please share your comments and your thoughts.


So i am an investor in bond markets and i am not so good at gambling or trading. I think one key difference is the approach. As an investor, i want to be aware of everything that i touch. I want to find value. I want to take a long term positions. To identify value, i will look at macro risk, industry risk, company specific risk, relative value and then assess the outside. Since i am aware of the risk, i can take a long term call.

A trader i believe thinks of payoffs. What is the loss given a risky event and the probability of a risky event. He will also assess the same for upside. And a positive outcome should be traded. Outlook is usually short term and most traders will not carry overnight risk. Medium term traders will trade on statistical levels.

I think the key difference is mindset and strategy. Just my 2 cents.

yes my friend, an investor is who doesn't afraid of taking the risk, he always thinks of the long term, and gambler is who always think of short-term profit.

Very good analysis my friend.
You truly demonstrated these two concepts.
upvoting and resteeming.

very much the difference gamble with investors, if the gamble requires a kosher capital that can only be used for gambling capital if there is no capital gai can gamble,
but if investors have to think first how to be able to find or measure first so can know how much capital we will spend for the project, yes sir that's just a comment from me, thank you

Hi sir in the world And its so fascinating is there a way you could share with me a good book todo learn those experiences about knowimg And mínimizing my losses and risk

It is much easier to resist gambling if you have ever suffered from a bad bet that was made from just a gut feeling as opposed to real data analysis. I can appreciate your analysis and I whole heartily agree.

Permission @lionindayard I came here to thank the people who have visited my house, a good coincidence, because I already know you and follow it.

Success is always for you, warm regards from me. 👌

Congratulation lionindayard! Your post has appeared on the hot page after 77min with 11 votes.

Congratulations @lionindayard! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of upvotes

Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.

To support your work, I also upvoted your post!
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here

If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Upvote this notification to help all Steemit users. Learn why here!

Yeah i would take the payout only because that is the smart choice, and im not greedy to take such a risk lol i play it safe for the most part. But if it was my other half im sure he would roll his luck lol

buena explicación yo me arriesgaria

Gamble: "To play at any game of chance for stakes. To stake or risk money, or anything of value, on the outcome of something involving chance."
Invest: "To put money to use, by purchase or expenditure, in something offering profitable returns."

I think Gambler is aim at profit-taking based on probabilistic logic and calculations.

an investor is trying to seek a profit based on rationality while a gambler with a gut feeling.

You are absolutely right in each of your words! Evidently, in order to have greater knowledge of the subject, not only do we have to reflect deeply, but also to support it in financial education.

Hello! I really like this kind of posts! Thanks for that!

Thanks lionindayard for sharing your post and visiting mine. Greetings.

Great contents!
Can I translate this posting to Korean language and post it to the Korean community Steemit? I will include the link to this posting.


Very good analysis my friend.
You truly demonstrated these two concepts.