It seems like your point is that the issue is far too complex to boil down to one simple talking point. That is more or less my point exactly. I make it differently, by pointing out that there is evidence of a potentially contradictory trend, but yes I agree this is obscenely complex and people who assume they know what is going to happen in the future because they have adopted an overly simplistic and politically generated narrative are deluding themselves. This article is not about the complexity of the ecosystem it is about looking at what the experts are saying about that complex ecosystem and forming logical conclusions. None of what I state is my opinion. This is a logical thought experiment not an opinion piece.
Thanks for your input, I think we agree.