I choose Option 1.
I have successfully eaten and now need to eat prior to the end of Day 4.
I have a knife.
For me, a knife is too important right now! Plus, if she has accomplices that try to jump me, I still have a knife to defend myself. (If this were actually happening I would also entertain the option of teaming up with her. First moving to a neutral location and then taking time to get a read on her and her let me see her supplies so she can't deceive me or jump me at night.)
Good luck everyone!! Peace!!