I have two answers. Usually when you post choices I have I hard time deciding, but I think the winter version of the photo is spectacular and far and away better. However, if you're asking where I'd live, I'd say neither. Even the second photo looks too cold for my taste! Trees without leaves makes me kind of sad, like I know winter is either about to come or hopefuly leaving.
Thanks for your thoughts and yes a very good point to live where the trees are always green and colors abound all year round would be my pick also
Have a great day