Welcome back and thank you for your contribution to @utopian-io!
Great to see you contributing again, and another excellent piece to start with.
Interesting to see that the total voting % to contributions fell in the months leading to December - The 75% in October 'feels' right and I would like to see the content again receiving the vast majority of the vote. I'm wondering if 'iamutopian' could have a section of its own, being a little like 'reviewer comments', but with a focus on the CMs review of the week.
Whilst this statement may be unpopular to some, I do feel that development should take the largest % of the vote - 51% for another category in November looks a little lob-sided and perhaps gives the heads at utopian-io something to think about going forward.
Although as stated by Amos, some good contributions missed getting a reward, I do feel that the review process itself works well, and 1.5-2 days is a reasonable turnaround with the manual process of the review, and the wait in the voting queue.
Well-written, superbly presented and chosen as a 'staff pick' for this week.
Asher [CM - Analysis]
Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian policies and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.
To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, click here.
Need help? Chat with us on Discord.
Hey Asher!
I agree on the total voting % to contributions - 75% does feel to me like the right sort of level for the 'core' purpose of Utopian and I'd like to see some tweaks to push it back in that direction.
I also think that development is the most important category and hearing that high-scoring development contributions were missing out on rewards is a little bit of a worry - it may discourage devs from engaging with Utopian / Steem. One possible change could be to increase the size of the development bucket (perhaps scaling in proportion to the maximum percentage reward for the category). Alternatively there could be a separate development bucket for Steem projects or VIPO projects or development-task-responses. All of this depends on what the goals / priorities are for Utopian.
I think the upvote timing is good now. Much better than when it was hovering around 6.5 days in any case!
Hey
Yes I didn't like to hear that decent (70+ scored) development contributions were missing out on rewards. Hopefully the recent adjustments stated by Amos can help with that.
Enjoy your weekend, I hear it's going to be a sunny one :)
Thank you for your review, @abh12345! Keep up the good work!