Thank you for extensive feedback. As @elear has already pointed out, we'll make this a bit more clear and encourage our moderators to leave solid feedback every time.
We want to move away from "accepted", "rejected" and the scoring process in these comments, but we want to make sure they contain reasonable and detailed feedback on the strengths and weaknesses of the contribution.
These comments are going to act as a guidance to improve yourself and the contribution (which could also lead to identifying scoring mistakes), rather than as an information of "Will I get paid?" which is not something we stand for.
Thank you for looking out for us. You just changed Utopian for better!