I agree with you points, and apologize for taking an aggressive tone in my first response.. That said, I have been at this game for a "long while".. and his understanding of Elliot wave is grossly in error the majority of the time. Hell, I will even put my money where my mouth is as I strongly believe in TA myself, as a practitioner..
If you ever have time, go through my reports and compare my calls to his. I will put 10 SBD on the line that I out perform him by several orders of magnitude on BTC, LTC, ETC etc.
I think in one of my more recent posts, I stated that I disagreed with his placement of axis in the descending wedge and redrew them accordingly. Where he felt we were in the channel I stated we were not and were being rejected after falling through the bottom..
Part of it is here: https://steemit.com/bitcoin/@pawsdog/1-31-2017-the-market-view-and-trading-outlook-actual-info
Here is another: https://steemit.com/bitcoin/@pawsdog/2-2-2018-the-market-view-and-trading-outlook
If we want to compare TA accuracy I will go head to head with him any day..
As someone whom has done this for a decade on the professional level and holds licenses related to the trade. I found his inability to accurately depict the simple most likely upper and lower boundary of a descending wedge to be somewhat egregious. That is in many respects very basic stuff based on experience and the rule set.