You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Dolphin Council: Proposed constitution, presented for comment

in #dolphincouncil5 years ago (edited)

Perhaps I'm missing the logic of background on this, but making a council where people are primarily qualified by being called a "dolphin" with 5K SP+ is a decent way to continue centralizing and segregating the heck out of this place. No offense. I really just don't understand this at all and would like to learn if you don't mind elaborating.

Sort:  

With 5000sp you need 200 accounts just to have a million. Cant centralize with that anyways. but a voice maybe. With all the recent events, ned, his lies, and power down, i see it as a desperate attempt by the people that just wanna protect their interests and steem

"desperate" eh?

lol who knows :)
thousands vs millions seems so to me

I would say it's not a competition.
Crypto is about community building.

oh yes it's certainly not meant to be competition for power.
but at the same time ned and a few other whales will always have enough control to nullify whatever council/community that may come up. we can't pretend they don't exist.

in the similar sense i like how @kabir88 plans on utilizing dpoll and the open discord channel because it's such nuance and perception that make all the difference. otherwise this dolphin council would be exactly the same as what haejin is doing.

I think the dolphin cutoff is a good starting point.
Once we have some more organization we can think about scaling up.
Any system with one:one person:vote needs some kind of limit so the votes don't get diluted.
If we decide to fund a project or punish bad behavior it is stake holders that can accomplish these goals.