You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: HiveGrove Campfire — Nov 6, 2026

in Hive Grove • 10 days ago

Public Consultation:

What is your opinion on selling lottery tickets for the strange sprout?

Type: Automatic registration when a ticket is available (no distinction between 5/10/15 points)

Price: 1 or 0.5 Hive?

Use Case: It's almost midnight, if I haven't gotten a Broto yet, I can buy the ticket and go to sleep knowing I'll be automatically registered.

The interesting thing is that these draws will be the most competitive, since everyone will try to get the Brotos before the reset.

Sort:  

I think that 1 HIVE is too expensive for winning a single "strange little sprout" (from 5 to 15 bonus leaderboard points, with an average of 10 points). 💸 0.5 HIVE may do, as it is still completely up to the #HiveGrove player whether to buy one or not. 🌱🧘‍♂️🤓

🤔🪙🌈🧠❤️👟🤝👍

As for me, this move remove the thrill and fun of it... Patiently waiting for your chance to find a sprout, diligently looking at new topic to find one...that's just for me.. I like being present, not paying to join.. It's frustrating if a sprout passed and I'm unable to join but I prefer being present if at all possible if I'm gonna join.

I agree. And it also "punishes" the people that wait here in the campfire patiently and engage in chatting to find a sprout.

I thought you will like this since the new sprouts & word missions has become too time consuming?

Then I misjudged your previous posts hehe.

So you prefer the current format of manually hunting for sprout?

Yeah it is time consuming.. But i prefer being present in the game I am involved in rather than pay to just be in the game. Like spl, I play on my own mostly... Then quit when I couldn't find time to play..

Agree. Although right now, the sprout hunting is time consuming, it's also the reason why we are all engaged and chatting at th campfire

Yes... Thats what made the game feel lively...

Yes. And a game needs active players. And Hive Grove does great with this compared to other Hive games. But this is also because of all the leaderboard missions.

I'm not paying to avoid effort. That's too sloth even for me. I prefer timed schedule sprouts. But I've never won any leaderboard spots that pay so far, so probably don't take my word for it. 😅

At the end of the day, I'm here to water trees. Everything else is just a bonus.

Yeah, completely understand that perspective (and the idea is that joining the lottery remains free) this is just like a drone that can make it easier (but doesn’t allow you to pick between 5/10/15 points), the idea is that it just creates another cashflow (which maybe can be directly put into reserve for the sustainability from old trees rather to leaderboard bonus @shiftrox)

Yes but there are 100 better ideas to create cashflow.

I think it's really a everyone's choice when playing the game. It's not forced to buy it, but maybe someone wants to get it for the leaderboard sprint. Timed sprout is not fun because everyone can set an alarm to join the sprout. It's just my POV

This might sound good to some players, but not to others. You see, I come here to water trees, my own as well as those of my fellow players. Oh, and I also come to listen to the music from @ravenmus1c 🎶🎵 I have a good time when I’m here, and whatever the majority decides, I’ll just have to accept it @shiftrox

Oh thank you so much! Happy you like the music! =)

I understand the need to generate cash flow, but alienating a portion of the players is not the most viable approach. Surely, a more in-depth analysis of the situation will lead to a sound idea and the right decision

I also agree. There are much better ways to create cash flow.

@shiftrox Good morning.i have a question. It it one time registration for whole day?

I think you can use the ticket as many times as you want until you win, so if you buy 3 tickets, you will automatically participate the first time, if you win, you won't use the other 2 anymore because you won the draw, now if you're unlucky you can participate in 3 draws and not win any of them.

I think that such tickets would become complicated if there is a separate type of ticket for the "strange little sprout", "mystery sprout", and "mystery word". 🌱🤯🤓

!PIZZA

🤔🪙🌈🧠👟🤝👍

In this case, can we create one ticket for each sprout? Should we create a ticket for the "word game" mission?

Would a ticket be refunded if the #HiveGrove player does not win from a "strange little sprout" for an entire day (UTC)? 🌱💸🤯😅

🤔🪙🌈🧠👟🤝👍

I agree with this proposal because, for someone like me who also has a job, I can't afford to stay glued to this game all the time, and I've been staying up for days waiting for the sprout, especially at night. This would be a huge help to avoid getting stressed.

Agreed. Same as farrahyne, I can't stay online all the time.

@mayt @frazfrea pleae take some time to read. And share your opinion about this. Thanks😎🌱

Regarding the price: It might be difficult to avoid setting an exact price (or one that’s as exact as possible), but you could set a price per unit, a lower price per unit if someone wants 2, and an even lower price if they buy 3. Or you could set two prices: one per unit and one for 3. For example, 1 Hive (one ticket) and 1.5 Hive (3 tickets). Or 0.8 Hive for one ticket, and if you buy more than one, each additional ticket for 0.5 Hive.

A strange little sprout has sprung up by the fire — it looks like it's got something to give. Tap Join on this message inside HiveGrove in the next 10 minutes for a shot at 10 bonus leaderboard points!

@frazfrea is the winner of this round's sprout draw among 6 players: +10 bonus leaderboard points!

@shiftrox A good idea, I like it

My sleep will improve on days like yesterday, I didn’t get the @magic-sprout all day so I stayed up later just to catch one (worked) but yeah yesterday I would had purchased a few tickets

Will it work on mistery sprout aswell or soley on strange sprout (My hope is to keep mistery sprout exclusive)

Great idea! this solves several problems at the same time

And it brings up one basic other problem at the same time... Players should be rewarded for taking time for the game, for paying attention here, for beeing active! And you give others the chance to just buy their way in.. While others might not have the money to do so. For me it´s a bad idea.

My wish is that whatever is decided regarding a lottery and the sale of tickets for participation in the "sprouts" (brotes) proves truly viable for all parties involved. If the goal is growth and, by extension, attracting more people then please study, analyze, and assess the consequences so that sound decisions can be made. As I mentioned, this is for the good of everyone that is to say, for the good of Hivegrove as a whole.

Yes, I totally agree. Whenever I’m faced with a more complex decision, I try to open it up to the public and gather feedback. I want to create an official channel within Hive Grove where we can discuss these kinds of things.

I don´t like the idea. Again this gives players an advantage that pay more money for the game... This is the completely wrong direction in my oppinion. You now have a point/leaderboard system where only some tasks include to pay money. And I think this should become no more. Don´t ruin your good system and the good game and commmunity by giving richer players more advantages.

This is what I mean when I say that this decision might please some players but not others, as not everyone has sufficient resources; remember that there are people who post on Hive and need their earnings almost as soon as each post expires after seven days. That is the reality for the majority

But in the end it´s not only about who pleases it, but what it does with the whole commununity and engagement in general. And engagement will go down, and players who have more money have an advantage. When is this ever good?

Exactly and if participation drops, so do the resources. I know this discussion will be very productive; although I’m aware that I don’t contribute much to the game itself, I truly enjoy it and admire its creation, the updates, and all the improvements that have been made. So, let’s keep the improvements coming in a way that benefits Hivegro rather than working against it. The goal is to attract more people, not the other way around

I very much enjoy the discussion and am grateful of your point of view as we all just try to improve the game 👍

Sure! And I’m glad that this is a project that’s making significant progress in the short term, that’s how it looks to me, even though I’m not an expert on the subject 🎮🕹️

This is what I think too!

I totally agree with you!

Interesting to hear the other perspective!

Interesting concept

Interesting perspectives, but I personally think it is drawn too extreme. It means you could make it easier to miss 1 (maybe 3) draws a day but you can’t pick in which you join.

The funds go to the community, plus it is an item everyone can request from the community. Also more people participating in a draw gives you less value for your lottery ticket.

Personally I think the lottery ticket will replace the drone as requested item.

The whole exodus scenario is what we would need to avoid

On that I agree, but that would be more like having a paid only lottery. Here I don’t think it is different from a drone.

But ofcourse, if it is likely to give unfair advantage then we should not do it

It is correct, I say it is time consuming.. But i spend time to games I like playing. I mostly wait even until after the daily reset to sleep when I'm behind too much points.. I have always play like this since I joined... I like interacting with other players as well... Others can opt to paying if they want to... It is not mandatory and just an option for a chance to gain some points..

Big shoutout to @shiftrox to put ideas up to discussion before making choices. Basicly the transparency and solid scrum approach is awesome!

It's a good idea to open up decisions like this to everyone. I want to set something up here later to make things easier—a poll thread or something like that—so that when I create it within the Hive Grove ecosystem, everyone will be able to post, vote, and so on.

On this specific idea - I am good with any outcome. If people feel that it risks damaging the game - we should not go for it, if the risk is neglectable I would like it.

Yeah, it can be implemented and test the waters... Others may join if they want... See the results for several days. Then he can decide whether to keep implementing or remove.

I'm sort of in two minds on this. On one hand, I would love this option, but on the other hand it will remove some incentive to be active.

Maybe set 4 different tickets up:
5 point: 0.3 HIVE
10 point: 0.5 HIVE
15 point: 0.85 HIVE
All draws: 0.7 HIVE

Each ticket should then have limited uses, maybe 6(?). The ticket will be removed when the player win a draw or after the 6 draws.
Point specific tickets could possibly have a lower limit, like 4 draws.

Mystery sprout and word game should not in

I like this idea...

Because it is a good idea 😆 At least I think it is - otherwise I wouldn't be suggesting it 😂


!BBH !ALIVE !HEARTBEAT !GLYPH !SLOTH !INDEED !HOPE !PEPE !WEIRD

@shiftrox That would be a fun idea to try! By the way, I'm not sure if I'm the only one who feels this way, but would it be possible to have a separate tab for "Grove Walk"? It's a bit cumbersome to find it under "Friends," and I think Grove Walk would be a fun feature to have on its own!