这两天浑元形意太极门掌门马保国被50岁业余武术爱好者王庆民30秒内击倒3次被昏迷的视频广为流传并引发群众们关于传统武术的热议。
(图源 ：pixabay)
那个视频还有大师之前的宣传视频我都看了，不得不说，大师还是很有范的，看他之前的宣传视频，我一下子就成了大师的粉丝，所以大师被KO的时候我是万分担心大师缓不过来。
还好，第二天就看到大师顶着熊猫眼，笑容满面对自己如何手下留情侃侃而谈，不得不说，大师就是大师，虽然败了，但是风度犹存。当然了，大师也不是真正的败了，要不是手下留情，鹿死谁手还真说不定呢！
不过因此引发的传统武术讨论对大大地出乎了我的意料，基本上把传统武术扁得一文不值，除了表演以外一无是处。
这不不算，一些自媒体竟然开始假打霍元甲，说什么霍元甲拳打外国大力士什么的都是假的，霍元甲怕挨打报了警，警察过来叫停了比斗。说的有鼻子有眼儿，仿佛就是当事人一样。
(图源 ：网络图片)
这还不算，有些人还掀开了鲁迅的棺材板，把鲁迅拉出来帮他们一起打假武术，说什么鲁迅抨击武术和中医一样都是大骗子，是要摒弃的封建糟粕，洋枪大炮才是好东西。
先不说霍元甲这事是真是假，反正霍元甲是没法出来喊冤了，这脏水自媒体随便怎么泼，能博眼球再换来几个打赏就最好了，才不怕霍元甲托梦给他呢。
但是关于鲁迅的话，我觉得脱离了社会背景以及谈话的场景上下文来断章取义，那真真就是耍流氓了。鲁迅的话大概是只凭武术不能保家也不能卫国，而没说武术一无是处。
在当时热兵器已经颇为发达的年代，想靠武术来强国，来和敌人血拼，那当然是不现实的。如果真有那么强大的武术，且能在战场上扭转乾坤，那一定是发生在抗日神剧里。
就好比现在不说热武器不说核威慑，就单单是贸易战、信息战、金融战这些种战争形态，大侠武功再高，也只能徒呼奈何吧？
那么武术真的是一无是处吗？当然不是，武术强身健体、锻炼平衡反应能力这些应该都是很有成效的，至于为什么打不过什么自由搏击、跆拳道等等，我觉得只能说各有擅长，大概都可能算作武术的范畴吧？不能说太极、咏春才算武术，其它的什么都不算吧？
其实之所以对武术这事颇多感概，大概是我小学的时候偶然发现家里一本破旧的《散手拳法》，里边一幅幅图解教了一些招式，现在大概除了记住一招赶步压肘以外，其它的招式我都记不住名字了，但是当时我用学来的招式从小学打到初中没有敌手。
当然了，我并不是用来欺负人，不过谁想欺负我的话，我绝招一出，准保他趴地上哭爹喊娘地求饶，这就是武术喽。
就好比一个大腹便便地油腻中年男，大街上被小偷抢了钱包只能呼喊而无能为力，而如果是一个有几把刷子的练家子，身体素质不差，那么最终倒霉的只能是小偷吧，这就是武术喽。
(图源 ：pixabay)
所以不要神化也不要贬低，神化起来无所不能，贬低起来一无是处，那样一点也不客观，也不科学。大师的失败，只是个人的失败，不能因此否定所有武术，何况有些本来就是打着武术的幌子招摇撞骗而已。
我相信对付很多平常人是有用的但毕竟缺少实战经验。
那些MMA，散打都是多些实战经验。
我也没看过你说这但八卦去搜了。
有兴趣的朋友，看这youtube吧。
总觉得师傅好像太急多过太极。可能少实战的关系急于出招而忘了平静先。
I have only studied some Karate and a bit of Hsing-i (aka Xing Yi chuan), but I remember that one of our black belt instructors was also a fan of MMA fighting, and he mentioned that some of the most effective MMA fighters at that time employed a combination of punching techniques, then quickly moving to close and grapple with their opponents, where they could restrain their opponent and often cut off their air supply.
This was about 25+ years ago though, so I can't say much about the current most successful methods of martial arts fighting. And it's also true that the limits imposed on what is allowed during stage fights makes it difficult to determine the most effective techniques if one finds oneself in a life-or-death situation.
Fight is a kind of experience. I think the MMA guy usually will have have an advantage in that sense because they usually spar and train with different kinds of people. I don't think there is ever going to be an unbeatable kind of martial arts but it's healthy to pick up some form and it's no so healthy to pick a fight. You could end up facing someone with the right Russian Systema or Israeli Krav Manga. 😎 I do taiji only for health reason.
Thats a good insight: I think it's probably true.
As for myself, I also try to avoid physical fights, my last was in high school many years ago :-) The closest thing to a physical fight for me nowadays is across a table tennis table, and even then I prefer friendly opponents.
But your point about experience with different styles is very true there: if you meet a table tennis player who is familiar with your style and you are not familiar with his, you will generally have a lot of trouble in that match...
能对付平常人就好喽
毕竟高手还是比较少的
何况一山还比一山高呢
沒想到你是深藏不露的高人哪~~~~
害怕不？
我一个可以打你100个
你是說你是十個葉問？真能吹啊~~~~
我觉得武术是武之艺术。攻击次要吧……防身健体主要..... 嘻嘻，愚妇之见 😂